INACCURATE FRAUDULENT AFFIDAVIT OF ANNE SANFORD AND KATHLEEN O’KEEFE WITHESSED BY SEAN NAUGHTON COMMISSIONER FOR OATHS ROSCOMMON

Sean Naughton Commissioner for Oaths, The Square in County Roscommon, the Affidavit you witnessed for Deponents Sanford and O’Keeffe on the 11th day of October 2021 is an INACCURATE FRAUDULENT document.

Anne Sanford does not live in Cork she resides at 31 Atwood Street, Wellesley, Mass  02482 USA.

The cautions affecting folios 8137F, 36155F, 9544F and RN40487F have base and foundation. The Cautions will not be removed from the properties belonging Patrick Gavin RIP until the demands Michael Gavin and  Eileen Linney are met. The manner in which the estate was dealt with constitutes Elder Abuse and FRAUD. Michael Gavin RIP was out of pocket in excess of €116,000 Department of Agriculture Grants.  Both Eileen Linney and Michael Gavin were shorted €12,500 each from Proceeds of the Land sale and a further €3,700 was deducted from Eileen Linney for cattle she never owned.

1.     Michael Gavin and his brother Pat lived together all their lives over 70 years in their humble home Dundonnell, Taughmaconnell in south Roscommon. After Pat died intestate on 10th October 2005, Michael Gavin continued farming and caring for the farm animals as he had always done. If Michael Gavin did not continue the farming of the land then the estate would not be entitled to claim the Entitlements.

2.     The family solicitor John Glynn wrote to each of the beneficiaries of Pat Gavin’s estate informing them of their entitlements. He also informed them that Michael Gavin wanted to forgo his share of the money left in Pat’s estate and compensate them additionally for the farm as he had worked it all his life and wished for it to be in his name.

3.     Robert Marren was suggested by a Barrister to administer the estate and this was agreed because no party knew Robert Marren prior.

4.     Anne Sanford got a Special High Court Summons in an attempt to sell the roof over Michael Gavin’s head stating in their sworn affidavit that the farm could not be sold without the farmhouse. Justice Mary Laffoy would not agree to this as Michael Gavin RIP had a right to reside in the farmhouse family home per his fathers will. “By notices in writing Kathleen ‘OKeefe, and Mary Theresa Harte have confirmed their desire to have the house and lands of the estate sold. Nicholas Duffy and his four children have also confirmed that they desire to have the property sold. It is also the wish of the Plaintiff that the property be sold.”

5.     Michael Gavin offered to compensate Anne Sanford, Kathleen O’Keeffe and the beneficiaries verbally and in writing countless times for the farm but they refused to entertain his wishes The lands were eventually auctioned and Anne Sanford, & Kathleen O’Keefe placed the winning bid, however did not close in the required 30 day time frame. The 2 sisters got the consent from the remaining next of kin to waive their share, so they were required to hand over just 1/3 of the purchase money with the agreed condition that they would cover the expenses associated with the Property Auction.

6.     To say that there were no bidders other than the family is untrue. The farm auction generated much interest and there were numerous bids from local farmers on the first parcel of land with the road frontage against Anne Sanford as Michael Gavin’s side did not place any bid on that parcel.

7.     Numerous written requests were made in vain for evidence that Anne Sanford and Kathleen O’Keeffe’s own personal funds were transferred to Robert Marren solicitor who was administrator. The Duffy and Harte families waived their interest in the estate to facilitate Sanford and O’Keeffe’s scheme.

8.     Anne Sanford and Kathleen O’Keeffe have succeeded in dividing the family with empty promises of a better deal than what the late Michael Gavin was prepared to give them. Michael went to work at 14 years of age under our fathers name to help feed the rest of the family and fund Kathleen O’Keeffe’s education in boarding school. He delivered loads of turf on a yearly basis to Duffy family in Athlone and did not deserve to be abused in his final years.

9.     Michael Gavin RIP DID NOT farm the lands freely and without question from October 2005 till 2014. Anne Sanford and Kathleen O’Keeffe’s numerous Solicitors tormented him with mentally abusive letters. After numerous written requests Robert Marren, Solicitor did indeed make a decision in March 2013 to accept Michael Gavin’s claim to owning half the livestock and all the sheep. Anne Sanford, Kathleen O’Keeffe and the family were no doubt happy with Marren’s decision to refuse to award Michael Gavin the net amount €116,789.11 due to him out of the Single Payment Entitlements representing his ½ share in the profits from farming the lands.

10.                 After Michael Gavin RIP passed Kathleen O’Keeffe and Anne Sanford leased the Farm lands to Lawrence Mc Manus from Pettigo, Co. Donegal Mobile No 083 113 3608 an alleged former IRA man who phoned Elderly Widowed Eileen Linney demanding that Eileen Linney hand over the keys to the house in Dundonnell, Taughmaconnell, Roscommon where Michael Gavin RIP lived all his life. Lawrence McManus claims to be a mediator and told Eileen Linney that he has a right by law to the keys and he proposes to sell the house in March 2019. He claimed to local person in a recorded phone conversation that all the family are in agreement to sell the home and he has filed signed agreement with the district courts. This is a LIE as Eileen did not sign any agreement with Lawrence McManus nor did she ever meet with him.  Sanford and O’Keeffe then instructed their Cork based solicitor Vincent Toher to send Eileen Linney 3 threatening letters poorly written confused letters full of grammatical and spelling errors.

11.            The truth prevails at all times slanderous as it may be for Sanford and O’Keeffe. Sanford and O’Keeffe objected to the departments of Agriculture Grants being paid to Michael Gavin and Michael had to repay the original monies that John Glynn solicitor gave him to pay Joe Murray’s bill for animal feed and farm supplies. Michael Gavin expressed his dissatisfaction on numerous occasions and lack of compensation including in correspondence mailed to Kathleen O’Keeffe on Date 22/06/2015. See copy of letter. John Glynn Solicitor suggested on their behalf that Mr. Robert B. Marren take the case back before a Judge for a decision to be made particularly how the department of agriculture grants were to be distributed bearing in mind that Michael Gavin RIP had minded the farm animals for over 9 years, and paid the associated expenses out of his own pocket.  This was a contentious issue as Michael Gavin RIP had been Tricked and led to believe by his two sisters Ann Sanford and Kathleen O’Keefe all along that he would be compensated.

12.                 For the record the administrator Robert Marren has not completed the distribution of the estate of Patrick Gavin Jnr who died intestate as the Farmhouse remains in Patrick Gavin Jnr name. It is apparent that  Robert Marren favoured the wishes of Anne Sanford and Katheen O’Keeffe. Tony Watson solicitor from the Law Society Ireland stated in writing on 29/06/2015 that Mr. Marren distributed the estate based on his client’s Sanford and O’Keeffe’s very clear instructions. John Glynn solicitor who sought justice for Michael Gavin RIP and Eileen Linney referred to Sanford and O’Keeffe as 2 vengeful and spiteful sisters who had already put the estate to enormous legal expense and whom would be prepared to waste further assets in further litigation. John Glynn solicitor also questioned whether Robert Marren’s hands were tied by instructions received from Messrs Sanford & O’Keeffe.

13.                  The above facts are the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth.

Suggest you read the following document as evidence:

Letter from Tony Watson Law Society Ireland 29/June/2015

Letter from John Glynn to Tony Henry 14/January/2015

Letter sent to Kathleen O’Keeffe and Sanford  22/June/2015

Letter from T & N Solicitors 03/July/2013

Letter from Robert Marren 05/July/2013

192 page Paper copy of File given to Garda Fraud

Financial Elder Abuse Book Second Edition ISBN 9781720333371

The Law is as Straight as a Door Jamb,It’s those that implements the Law that’s CROOKEDHave a Nice DayMichael Gavin RIPhttps://twitter.com/MichaelGavin83
https://www.facebook.com/michaelgavin83/
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCe7ZmEXJVgkpLwfsOD9G9Sw
https://michaelgavindundonnell.wordpress.com/

 Financial Elder Abuse Book Second Edition Amazon https://amzn.to/2ZmdCtC

Why does Vincent Toher Cork Solicitor Rub his balls in public?

Why does Vincent Toher Cork Solicitor Rub his balls in public?

One might ask why do we wittiness Vincent Toher Cork Solicitor Rub his balls in public court rooms?

According to Rob Kominiarek, a family physician and founder of the Alpha Male Medical Institute.

It Helps Towrag Assert His Dominance Facing a business rival with his hands in his pants could mean he’s consciously or subconsciously trying to establish who’s boss. Telling other guys to back off by pointing to his junk helps him mark his territory, he says.

Evolutionarily speaking, he who mates the most wins – even if these days, that means landing clients and accounts rather than producing offspring.

Might also explain why he chooses to be pictured along with all his female staff.

TOWRAG Vincent Toher Solicitors

WHY DID TOWRAG VINCENT TOHER SOLICITOR SCRIBE THREATENING LETTER TO DEFENSELESS WIDOW

TOWRAG Vincent Toher Solicitors

TOWRAG,
WHAT AUTHORITY HAVE YOU TO SCRIBE A THREATENING LETTER TO DEFENSELESS WIDOW.
EXAMINE THE DOCUMENTATION ASSOCIATED WITH THE CAUTIONS  PLACED ON  8137F, 36155F, 9544F AND RN40487F FOR BASE AND FOUNDATION.
DO NOT CONTACT ME AGAIN, CONTACT THE SOLICITOR WHO SIGNED THE CAUTIONS IF YOU AND YOUR CLIENTS HAVE THE BALLS.

My 2 sisters Ann Sanford and Kathleen O’Keefe reported John Glynn Solicitor of Patrick Hogan and Co. Ballinasloe, to Law Society.   The Law Society advised John Glynn to step aside.  John Glynn continued to assist my Brother Michael Gavin RIP and I Eileen Linney with correspondence on our behalf (unletter Headed) to Mr. Robert B. Marren Solicitor Mullingar the appointed Administrator for Patrick Gavin’s Estate.  When Mr. Robert B. Marren issued the distribution statement it was apparent that he favoured our sisters wishes.

We challenged him on a number of points and John Glynn Solicitor suggested on our behalf that Mr. Robert B. Marren take the case back before a Judge for a decision to be made particularly how the department of agriculture grants were to be distributed bearing in mind that my late brother Michael Gavin RIP had minded the farm animals for over 9 years, and paid the associated expenses out of his own pocket.  This was a contentious issue as my brother Michael Gavin RIP had been Tricked and led to believe by his two sisters Ann Sanford and Kathleen O’Keefe all along that he would be compensated.

 Mr Marren responded by threatening my brother Michael Gavin RIP and I that if we did not engage a solicitor, he intended to proceed and distribute the estate assets according to the original distribution statement. John Glynn Solicitor spoke and wrote to Tony Henry Tormeys Solicitors, Athlone. 

Tony Henry Tormeys solicitors failed to undertake the instructions given him by John Glynn.   Tony Henry also failed to inform us, that he would not carry out those instructions.  Therefore Robert Marren distributed the estate assets in isolation to my brother Michael Gavin RIP and my objections.  

FOR THE RECORD. My brother was out of pocket in excess of €116,000 Department of Agriculture Grants.  Both my brother and I were shorted €12,500 EACH from Proceeds of the Land sale and a further €3,700 was deducted from me for cattle I never owned.

Our demands are the following:  That from the date that Mr. Robert B. Marren received and withheld funds from my late brother Michael Gavin RIP and I Eileen Linney, an interest rate of 8% is accruing to our account plus expenses, because of Mr. Robert B. Marren’s failure to make good on our legitimate claim or take the matter back to the courts for a Judge to decide.  The above has been written to and email to Marren and his state Solicitor Peter D. Jones numerous times, but no reply. 

This File given to Garda Fraud and contains the full details and evidence of the FRAUD and Financial Elder Abuse endured by my deceased Brother Michael Gavin and I Eileen Linney.

https://t.co/4aZSZCUA9N


The Law is as Straight as a Door Jamb,It’s those that implements the Law that’s CROOKED

Here are some of the comments and messages we are receiving on

TOWRAG

Hi folks
I have Vincent Toher his daughter Mary Toher and 2 of his barristers up in front of the LRSA ,I have asked the LRSA to strike them off and criminal charges need brought .

Thanks”
Gerry

BULLY LAWRENCE MCMANUS THREATENS TO SELL MICHAEL GAVIN'S RIP HOME

BULLY LAWRENCE MCMANUS THREATENS TO SELL MICHAEL GAVIN’S RIP HOME

BULLY LAWRENCE MCMANUS THREATENS TO SELL MICHAEL GAVIN'S RIP HOME

BULLY LAWRENCE MCMANUS THREATENS TO SELL MICHAEL GAVIN’S RIP HOME

Eileen Linney has no intention of handing over any keys until what was
ROBBED from her and her deceased brothers estate is returned with
interest from the dates it was stolen.
Listen to Bully Lawrence McManus LIE.

https://youtu.be/B8dc9T94iVs

He has NO agreement signed by Eileen.
Bully Boy Lawrence McManus 083 113 3608 #Pettigo Co #Donegal
who was Expelled from the Sinn Féin party is now demanding that
Elderly Eileen Linney hand over the keys to the house in Dundonnell
Taughmaconnell Co Roscommon where Michael Gavin RIP lived all
his life.
Lawrence McManus currently has cattle on the lands that Michael
Gavin RIP farmed all his life with his brother Pat Gavin RIP.

Lawrence McManus claims to be a mediator and told Eileen that he has
a right by law to the keys and he proposes to sell the house in March
2019.

We will continue our fight for Justice for Michael Gavin RIP by
protesting outside corrupt Solicitors offices in Athlone and Mullingar.

Robert B Marren Castle Street Mullingar
Tony Henry Tormeys Solicitors Athlone
Tony McLynn Athlone
Peter D Jones Mullingar

Please Call their offices for further information on the protests and let
them know that you support Michael Gavin RIP.

Robert Marren +353449343826
Tony Henry Tormeys Solicitors 090649 3456
Peter Jones +353449343697
Tony McLynn +353906498264
Lawrence McManus 083 113 3608

MemorialCard-2
Michael Gavin RIP Died on 21st December 2017
Blessed Oscar Romero said “The ones who have a voice must speak for
those who are voiceless.”

CON MAN LAWRENCE MC MANUS RECORDED LYING

Lawrence McManus – Hello

Derek McCabe – Good Morning can I speak to Lawrence Mc Manus?

Lawrence McManus – Ye

Derek McCabe – Lawrence

Lawrence Mc Manus – Yes

Derek McCabe – I’ve being told here locally that you are involved in a
house repossession order in March 2019 is that correct?

Lawrence McManus – aaa

Dereck McCabe – in Dundonnell, Taughmaconnell

Lawrence Mc Manus – I am the mediator working on the case but I
can not discuss it with you.

Derek McCabe – You’re the mediator are you working on behalf of
the defendant or the plaintiff ?

Lawrence McManus – (LIES)– I am working on behalf of the whole
family (LIES)

Derek McCabe – and are you advocating that that family not leave that
property in March

Lawrence McManus – Do what?

Derek McCabe – and are you advocating that that family not leave that
property in March

Lawrence McManus – Am I advocating that they are not, who am I
speaking to first of all

Derek McCabe – Dereck McCabe

Lawrence McManus – Yes well I can’t discuss it with you

Derek McCabe – You will come to know me in March because I wont
all that family be taken out of their house.

Lawrence McManus – There is nobody living in the house the house is
vacant.

Derek McCabe – The house is vacant that’s right but it’s in the family
name

Lawrence McManus (LIES) The whole family has agreed that the
house is going to be sold (LIES).

Derek McCabe – Why though? Because of your words?

Lawrence McManus (LIES) No not my words, they want to sell it,
they want it done, its dusted (LIES).

Derek McCabe – Can you confirm the family said that because I
spoke to them and they don’t want to sell it.

Lawrence McManus – (LIES) All of the family want to sell it, I
have a letter of authorisation from all of them.

Derek McCabe – is the authorisation done thoroughly through the
district court?

Lawrence McManus – Yes Yes

Derek McCabe – and you can confirm that?

Lawrence McManus – Yes no bother yes sure why not

Derek McCabe – No I don’t believe you one bit, because I believe that
you pushed them over the edge to sell that house, you bullied them, I
work legally myself Lawrence.

YouTube recording Link https://youtu.be/B8dc9T94iVs

The ones who have a voice must speak for those who are voiceless.

Please Sign

http://chng.it/7xPStCrQxm

Read

https://bit.ly/2QiK6kv

Watch

 

Financial Elder Abuse Book by Michael Gavin Comments

Financial Elder Abuse Book by Michael Gavin Comments

 

Financial Elder Abuse Book by Michael Gavin Comments

Financial Elder Abuse Book by Michael Gavin Comments

Financial Elder Abuse Book by Michael Gavin Comments

“Well written account of the injustice perpetrated against an innocent man
aided and abetted by the Irish legal profession to steal this elderly man’s
money from him. The solicitor should be charged and jailed.”

“This is a very sad case of an elderly man being cheated by the law. It’s
very detailed and definitely worth a read, cases like this abound in Ireland,
where people will behave in truly shameful manner where land is
concerned.”

“Shocking Corruption Exposed by Elderly Farmer. This is Rural Ireland
2015. You won’t see this on 6.01 News.”

Free PDF Financial Elder Abuse

https://bit.ly/2QiK6kv

Original Book on Amazon

https://amzn.to/39gC1Wn

New Colour Edition

https://amzn.to/2ZmdCtC

Number 1 Book for Exposing Solicitors Financial Elder Abuse.

“To commit fraud is an offense in Ireland. But the prosecution for such
will depend very much on where you reside on the social scale #vinb”

“This story highlights the blue-shirt mentality of current regime. People
should read it and stand up against FG cowards and Bullies.”

“This type of practice is unacceptable and must undergo a radical
review and renewal. Irish people, be they farmers or academics (one
doesn’t exclude the other) trust these kind of professions to represent
their clients’ interests. In this case it seems like that trust was exploited
for personal gain.”

“This is Disgusting Travesty of Justice these Solicitors should be disbarred
from Practicing for this ABUSE of their Position they are Traitors to our
People Greedy disgusting Cretins who should be arrested & Jailed for their
terrible ABUSE of this Man! WE are watching from Afar & We promise
you we will get Justice for this Man!”

“This is the saddest story I have heard in all my fifteen years in
Ireland. it is sad because it predicts the future and yet no-one cares
because you are asleep. You Irish have made for yourself a bed of nails
through your gutlessness and apathy. And let hell skelp it into ye.”

“His estranged family will have no luck for this. Denying water and
shelter to someone is not part of our culture. What goes around comes
around I’ve seen it happen before, maybe not this generation but the next.
A curse on them.”

“Irish law society closed ranks apparently facilitating the denying of justice
to an elderly farmer.”

“Hi Mike I have just read the whole story from beginning to end an
utter disgrace very sad totally unjust . Can’t find the share button. I do
hope that things will go right for him. The expense so far is unreal”
“What else should be expected in Ireland today. The real issue is too many
have the attitude of I’m all right jack so f*** you”

“Cases like this one rely on secrecy, sharing on social media may deter
future fraud occurring within families regarding the beneficiaries of a will,
it’s far too common.”

“As an Irish American dealing with a case with similarities there is no
justice in this country for seniors…it should be reported in the media in the
states. I will be doing so, have Sean Hannity get involved on Fox news he
hates injustice!!”

“the mob in the legal world have no honour, respect or fairness its all about
Money”

“its a disgrace what has being done to this man and its theft ,,, so robert
marren should be charged with theft , and its shame on tony mclynn
solicitors for taking this case and for their huge fees they charged which is
also theft, corruption at its best under the law”

“The Lawless Society are hell bent on benefitting themselves through
legalised theft. Hiding themselves behind the Law and corrupting it, yet
they cannot be tried for their crimes, because they run the courts.”

Mairead Gallagher -How shocking.! This poor gentleman suffering as
a result of white collar corruption. The law Society are self-regulating
and all you can do is expose this into a public arena where they are
named and shamed! It’s a total travesty and hopefully this nasty
Solicitor will be exposed to such a degree where it cannot be ignored!
It’s the only way Society can change. These individuals have been
protected in the past, but they should not continue in being allowed to
be a self-regulating body. There should be an independent body / group
set up who monitors complaints made against these practising
Solicitors who engage in lies, fraud and corruption!.

Mike Real – The Solicitor Marren should have gone before a Judge
instead of squandering the Dept. of Agriculture Grants and favouring
the wishes of Michael Gavin’s devious sisters Kathleen o Keefe and
Anne Sanford.

Paul Lally – Its time to start executing solicitors barristers and
judges that flout the law and rob people of their hard earned money. If
any of the above steal 10,000 they should get jail, If any of the above
steal 100,000 they should be castrated first then jailed for life, If any
of the above steals land of an elderly man they should get instant death
by 1000 cuts. This is the law of my land I don’t know about yours.
Martha Higgins – This is disgraceful to do this to an old man. Take
away the license of the solicitor Marren, he’s corrupt!

Kieran Doherty – Every corrupt solicitor in this country should be
exposed.

Podge Foley – Disgusting weasels.

Sean Simon – Solicitors steal all of the time We Are the Capital
Country of White Collar Crime why because its almost impossible to
prove and when it’s proven you don’t go to jail just give the money
back.

Padraig Kelly – This should be investigated fully.

James Maidment – Solicitors are a crowd of gurriers, cheating
people out of money and as usual, dishonest thieving bastards.

Sandra Fitzgerald – I hate bullying and injustice.

Pam White – Disgraceful they must think themselves so superior to
everyone else.

Brian Coyle – Yes time to wise up, the one thing that scares them is the
truth .

Benedicte Morris – Greed is disgusting.

Cathy Russell – It’s a shocking story.

Lisa White – Best of luck Michael, sickening what the money men can
get away with in this country.

G Gallagher – It’s high time this so called Republic takes a stand for
the vulnerable.

Jeanette Campbell – This is all criminal !

Toni Hynes – It is so wrong. How dare that solicitor do what he has
and is still doing. He should be prosecuted and jailed for what he is
doing. He should be suspended from practising till this is sorted and
because of the age of Michael, it should be seen as urgent.

Pat Cannon – I am signing because I am sick of all the fraud that is
been perpetrated against the ordinary working class people of
Ireland by the so called ruling classes and especially the Judiciary /
legal profession.

Eileen Murphy – We need to be encourage in the face of any kind of
abuse. This desperately needs to be exposed.

Joseph O’Connell – Too much corruption in Ireland today that is from
the top down.

Marion Guinan – Elderly people have rights

Philip Kavanagh – I had dealings with incompetent and lying
solicitors.

Beverley Scott – The level of corruption in the UK and Ireland is
disgusting! It has to STOP

Oliver Stack – I’ve had the bad experience of dealing with a corrupt
solicitor in the past. I hate to see anyone else go through the same
thing.

Anne Marie Lankester – The law recognises Elder Abuse so it must
enable victims to seek redress and prosecute such fraudsters – or why
bother to create the law in the first place?

Damien Smith – White collar crime is still crime. The legal profession
have alot to answer for.

Marie Harper – I despise people being taken advantage of.

Spudser Dayid – A full investigation needs to be carried out by An
Garda Siochana into the behaviour of solicitor Robert B Marren
Mullingar

Ena Foley – These very crooked Solicitors must not be allowed to
defraud any more elderly people and behave like the crooks they really
are. Thinking themselves above the law and behaving like the criminals
most of them know they are. If they weren’t criminals in disguise they
would be the HUNTED.

Vincent Hughes – Dreadful behaviour of a solicitor who is disguised as
a crook.

Mary Frain – This is a shocking case of corruption on the part of
Solicitor in attempting to steal this family home!!

Yvonne Tierney – Justice needs to win out here and questions need
answers.

Anne Keown – Disgusted with the underhanded way this man’s home
is been dealt with.

Joseph Kennedy How sad that a once lovely country has become so
evil…

June mc Mahon – How dare the solicitor abuse the family that put trust
in them.

David Louks – So it is OK to steal from the elderly? This solicitor is a
not a solicitor. He is a thief and needs prosecuted.

Carmel Toner – Too many crooks in this business! Time they were all
held accountable.

Graham Morgan – Because we need to tackle any sort of corruption in
Ireland.

Tommy O Connor – Evil solicitors.

Tom Hutchinson – That’s yet another crooked solicitor’s ways
exposed. We all know there’s plenty more legal scum like him.

Elizabeth Davis – Corrupt people need to know they will be exposed
for the crooks they are

Edward b – The corruption in this country has to be stopped by the
Irish people for all the people and shameful to treat Michael in this
way.

Frank McCaffrey – I am supporting this petition because these poor
people not getting any help and the worry and distress is not right

John Mooney – Corrupt legal system, not fit for purpose.

Linda Keneamly – Let’s finish the job and give the old man some
peace of mind.

Jennifer Duffy – This is elder abuse and they should not be allowed to
abuse their power as solicitor’s to think they are above the law.

Orla Douglas King – Day light robbery!!

Michael Hyland – Justice.

Phil Maher – Because all solicitor’s should be brought to account.

Mick Eccles – too many valid questions and no answers.

Bea O Neill – Justice needs to be done as soon as possible for this man
and his sister.

Fiona Ryan – Elder abuse is unacceptable.

Philomena Cornu – Because I Believe in Justice & Fair Play! I am
appalled at how this Rotten Corrupt Solicitor has been allowed to get
away with such Thievery as that is what it is Pure & simple! I Demand
Justice for Michael Gavin on Behalf if OUR PEOPLE POWER ABU!
JUSTICE & VICTORY OVER CORRUPT Irish Solicitor & Corrupt
Judiciary ABU!

Carmel Hoy – Shame on us for allowing our system to allow this to
happen.

Greg Doran – We need to prevent the on-going abuse of our people
and land.

Martin Davis – To get rid of this sham judicial system.in the ROI.

Sandra Mccague – This corruption needs to be stopped

Theresa Shanahan – I’m sick of greed and corruption.

Alan Byrne – Praying on Our elder’s. Horrible.

Wolfe Moore – I believe a grave injustice has been done and am aware
of the regularity of same …

Bridget Kenny – This is unbelievable how can anyone treat our elderly
like this. They have worked all their lives.

Helen Mc cabe – I stand with justice for Michael Gavin.

Dilip Ingale – because of injustice fairness for all not Chosen get rid of
all greed

William Duke – Corruption of the highest order. Stamp it out. Pay the
man his dues.

Sarah Mulligan – Greedy lying thieves probably don’t believe they’ll
ever be put to Justice in This Rip off Ireland. Hope they’re proved
very wrong by the people off Ireland.

Mary Kelly Godley – It is important to highlight this as there are a
myriad of injustices going on in this country that involve often
Solicitors who are acting in very dubious ways. Elder abuse needs to be
stamped out but so too does abuse of power by some unsavoury
characters among the Irish Legal Profession. Drain the Swamp.

Helen P Power – Disgusting.

Denis Moynihan – This man is been cheated out of what is rightly
his. Why can’t the Government step in on this gentleman’s behalf.

Hannah Todd – He should be held to account for his actions. Taken to
court and imprisoned.

Majella Meade – Too many corrupt solicitors getting away with theft.

Hazel Robinson – It’s appalling in this day and age.

Tracy Poynton – It’s a sin to take from the poor to give to the greedy
but more important it was stolen from the poor and squandered for the
greedy give this man his money.

Kerrie Williams – The financial corruption in this country has got to
STOP!!! Everyone involved in this corruption WILL BE
DISCLOSED sooner or later!!!!

Angela Kaplan – JUSTICE WILL BE DONE.

Tammy Harty – Because I think it’s disgusting how this man is made
feel respect goes along way.

Therese Huchinson – This man Deserves to get justice.

Lloyd Carroll – It’s the right thing to do.

Vera Twomey – We love our parents and older relatives and friends
they deserve respect as they worked hard all their lives.

David Cuffe – Corruption.

Melissa McKeague – The money was “just resting” in the account??
Talk about adding insult to injury– a disgrace to his profession!

Amy Mooney – also a victim of dirty dealing solicitors and the courts
system who colluded to kidnap my children along with social workers
and the police this country needs to change and I am behind true justice
every step of the way this is a utter disgrace xxx.

Michael 0’Sullivan – Justice should always be done.

Vernon Loughran – Don’t like bullies.

Charlie Cullen – I’m signing because I hate the way solicitors are
abusing their position and holding this country to ransom. They are a
disgrace to their profession!!!!

Margaret Flanagan – This is such a disgrace abuse at its best.

Fintan Callan – It a dictator country

Robbie Fallon – Ì am in full support.

Anna Harvey – It is a Disgrace what Robert Marren Has Done to
Michael Gavin he should be locked up for the rest of his life behind
bars as he is nothing but an Animal and a thief May he rot in HELL.

Sarah Mulligan – I’m an activist for the prevention of Elder Abuse.

Sue Byrne – I’m sick of people being ripped off between the
government, solicitors and barristers. Give this man what is owed to
him.

Patricia Richardson – Because everyone that had anything to do with
Robbin this man should be in jail.

Catherine Kennedy – I’m sick and tired of corruption in our country.

Harry Price – I am aware of the dealings in the secret society of
Blackhall Place Dublin and the corruption to be found covered up
there.

Patrick Mcshane – I hate thieves.

Bea O Neill – This is not acceptable in this day and age.

Mary Smyth – The corruption in this country has to be stopped.

Maire Ui Mhaolain – Protect the elderly.

Mary Sherry – I’m tired of the corruption in this country.

Kieran Doyle – Theft is theft simple.

Anne Smyth – I’m sick of the corruption in this country!

Donna Brennan – To highlight the corruption.

MIRIAM SHERRY – Mr Michael Gavin deserves justice starting with
Mrs Frances Fitzgerald The Law Society.

Martin Colfer – This form of abuse needs to be eliminated.

Columb Fogarty – I heard this man’s story.

Mary Furey – It’s about time this was stopped.

Frank Murray – Our judicial system is corrupt to the bone.

Susan Jackson – I can’t believe this is still going on.

Anthony mc Donald Mc Donald – We are all sick and tired of the
corruption in Irelands elite n political classes.

Sean Caughey – This is so wrong.

Shazie Brennan – Why let this corrupt, people get away doing this to
an elderly man, probably thought they get away with it, cause he’s
elderly, or hope he kicks the bucket no one will cop on thank God he
has some good friends to help him, spread this on the Internet, how
many more has this happen to we are unaware of good luck !!! Xx

William Moran – These guys seem to be the untouchables in our
Country for two long.

Ian Owen – it’s obvious.

Paddy Manning – This terrible injustice against an old man needs to be
put to right.

Anne Matthews – This is grossly unfair, and unjust. In fact, it’s
downright despicable, the way this man, and his family are being
treated.

Brian Lambert – Signing in Solidarity with 85 Year Old Michael
Gavin.

Catherine Mulhare – Justice for Michael Gavin fighting for justice at
his age strength to keep going, inspirational man, elderly abuse needs to
stop!! Michael Gavin needs to relax at his age not suffer this as unfair
& behind him 100 %.

Michael Mooney – Greed and corruption is widespread and will
continue to be covered up until you (and me included) decide to help
others to expose it.

Murth Hogan – I want those involved in white collar crime to be
brought to justice.

Linda Gallagher Farouk – I in my 11th year being harassed and
framed by Gardaí, judges & solicitors, I believe it’s time we all
exposed the corruption in Ireland. Either Ireland’s leaders or Justice
System does something about it, or God Willing, I will.

Jacinta Black – Disgraceful treatment.

Mick Morrissey from Co Waterford – “The professions are worse
than Dick Turpin ever was. Disgraceful behaviour meted out to this
poor man.”

Most Rev Dr Michael Desmond Hynes from Greenore, – “A very
very sad situation for Michael Gavin Herd Keeper.”

Johnny Keenan – “fair play to Michael, his family and friends for
standing up to these bullies. The suits need to be taken to the cleaners.
2016 is the year of the downtrodden. Good luck and up the rebels.”

John from Kinnegad – “This is a disgrace. Robbers in suits they
should be in jail.”

Liam Canavan from Co Kerry – “There are so many questions to be
answered in this case. I hope the protest around there is strong.”

Robert McEvoy from San Antonio, TX – “I have a similar letter from
the law society and I am waiting for the estate to be administered since
the death of the disponer on Oct 2013. I believe I was taken advantage
of because i live out of the country…”

Noreen Buckley from Ireland – “This is scandalous, all Solicitors
need to be investigated. Too many cases of elder abuse go undetected
through fear.”

Rob McGuirk from Dublin, – “Our country has become a black circus
lead by evil, greedy clowns. With continuous fight, and courage like by Michael Gavin there is still hope that being Irish cansomeday be something to be proud of again. Pay this man his money.”

James Manning from Shefford, United Kingdom – “Dear Michael I
live in England but have close personal ties to your part of the world
and the farming community there. I wish you every success in your
fight for a little justice in an increasingly sordid world.”

Jane Tyrrell Medical Secretary at St James Hospital, Balham,
London – This is diabolical For God’s sake the man is in his eighties
stop making what’s left of his life a misery He doesn’t need pen pushers
deciding what’s right for him let him stay in his home you greedy
family He’ll be dead soon because of you vultures and then you can do
what you like with the property You are all disgusting.

Joan Stringer from Pottstown, PA – “I support Michael Gavin and
stand behind him as a vital human being and an elderly man who
deserves his compensation!”

Noreen from Cavan, – “This type of practice is unacceptable and must
undergo a radical review and renewal. Irish people, be they farmers or
academics (one doesn’t exclude the other) trust these kind of
professions to represent their clients interests. In this case it seems like
that trust was exploited for personal gain.”

John O’Mahony from Dublin, – “Irish law society closed ranks
apparently facilitating the denying of justice to an elderly farmer.”
Stephen Gilgunn from Paris, France – “This situation needs to be
sorted now so this man can have some peace.”

Garrett David O’Mahony from Co Kerry – “The Law societys
former land and conveyancing solicitor is Fergus Appelbe Bandon Co
Cork. a convicted fraudster who forged documents. Google it. and
Google Colm Murphy Kenmare too. He fought the corrupt law society
and won.”

Janice Montalto from St. Petersburg, FL – “This elder should
absolutely receive the grant monies due him. And the 9 yrs back
payment that was stolen from him.”

Anne O Brien from Kenmare, – “Seems like terrible abuse of old
people by greedy legal people.”

Liz Keenan from Stockton, United Kingdom – “Think it is a disgrace
how Michael has been treated.”

Katherine Winters from Newry, United Kingdom – “Completely
unacceptable!”

Spudser Dayid from Co Cork, – “Stop Elder Abuse”.

Deirdre McNamara – “Some of these are clearly descendants of those
who stole the relief meal from the starving Irish during the Famine.”

Free PDF Financial Elder Abuse

https://bit.ly/2QiK6kv

Original Book on Amazon

https://amzn.to/39gC1Wn

New Colour Edition

https://amzn.to/2ZmdCtC

 

 

 

Robert Marren Solicitor Threatens Court Application against Michael Gavin’s RIP Widowed Sister Eileen Linney

 

Marren-Glynn-22-August-2019Marren,

In response to your letter to John Glynn Solicitor dated 22nd August 2019 we will state the following and send it to your office and home address in Mullingar via Registered Post as we have done with previous correspondence which you ROBERT B MARREN have choose to IGNORE..

After Michael Gavin RIP met with you once in your office Castle Street Mullingar he was of the opinion that you were as Crooked as a dog’s hind leg,Michael often remarked that he heard the old people say that The Law is as straight as a door Jamb; it’s those that implements the Law that are CROOKED.

Although you Marren are well aware that the Law Society of Ireland advised John Glynn to step aside you continue to squander the estate assets by writing to him.

Now you  Threatens Court Application to force me to sign your form 36 and squander more estate assets.

There is an alternative for you and you clients contained in the previous correspondence sent to you and your clients in May/June 2019 copy enclosed again.

As I have advised you in previous correspondence from the date you received and have withheld funds from my widowed sister Eileen Linney and I an interest rate of 8% per Month is accruing to the benefit of our accounts plus expenses because of your failure to make good on our legitimate claim.

Here is a link to file that was sent to DPP https://goo.gl/ryaqsf

Here is copy of previous correspondence sent to you registered post and email which you Ignored.

Marren,

Why did you contact John Glynn in April 2019 re signing Land Registry Form 36 for House at Dundonnell, Taughmaconnell, Roscommon. As you are well aware your clients Kathleen O’ Keefe and Anne Sanford reported John Glynn to the Law Society of Ireland and they advised him to step aside.

My late brother Michael Gavin RIP and I responded to your previous request for our signatures on form 36 back in October 2017.

Why did you and or your clients fail to respond. (copy of the letter we sent you is included below.)

Did you hire Lawrence McManus 083 113 3608 Pettigo, Co Donegal to mediate the sale of the property at Dundonnell Taughmaconnell Roscommon?

Why did Lawrence McManus 083 113 3608 Pettigo, Co Donegal phoned me demanding that I, Eileen Linney hand over the keys to the house in Dundonnell, Taughmaconnell, Roscommon where Michael Gavin RIP lived all his life.

Lawrence McManus claims to be a mediator and told me Eileen Linney that he has a right by law to the keys and he proposes to sell the house in March 2019.

Donal Jackson from Athlone who met with Lawrence Mc Manus on my behalf formed the impression that McManus is/was a member of the IRA.

Mc Manus was expelled from Sinn Fein but we are unsure why.

In a recorded conversation between Lawrenace McManus and Derek McCabe https://youtu.be/B8dc9T94iVs Monkesland Athlone. McManus claims he has the agreement of all the family to sell the house in Dundonnell, Taughmaconell and claims he has filed the necessary paperwork with the district court. This is a lie because I Eileen Linney did not sign any agreement with Lawrence McManus nor did I ever meet with him.

We have spoken to people in Donegal namely Shauna Veronica Tynan friend to Bridget Dillon and they claim that McManus has a history of tricking the elderly out of money up there.

As it stands McManus and his son are using the farmlands in Dundonnell to graze their cattle which is strange bearing in mind that its at least a 3 hour drive from Pettigo.

A brief history of what happened.  My 2 sisters Ann Sanford and Kathleen O’Keefe reported John Glynn to law Society.   The Law Society advised John Glynn to step aside.  John Glynn continued to assist us with correspondence on our behalf (unletter Headed) to you  Marren.  When you Marren issued the distribution statement it was apparent that you favoured our sisters Ann Sanford and Kathleen O’Keefe wishes. We challenged you on a number of points and suggested that he take case back before a Judge for a decision to be made particularly how department of agriculture grants were to be distributed bearing in mind that my late brother Michael Gavin had minded the farm animals for over 9 years, and paid the associated expenses out of his own pocket.  This was a contentious issue as my brother Michael Gavin RIP had been led to believe by his two sisters all along that he would be compensated.

YOU Marren responded by threatening us that if we did not engage a solicitor, you intended to proceed and distribute the estate assets according to the statement. John Glynn spoke and wrote to Tony Henry Tormeys Solicitors, Athlone.   Tony Henry Tormeys solicitors failed to undertake the instructions given him by John Glynn.   Tony Henry also failed to inform us, that he would not carry out those instructions.  Therefore you Robert B Marren distributed the estate assets in isolation to my brother Michael Gavin RIP and my objections.

FOR THE RECORD. My brother was out of pocket in excess of €116,000 Department of Agriculture Grants.  Both my brother and I were shorted €12,500 EACH from Proceeds of the Land sale and a further €3,700 was deducted from me for cattle I never owned.

Our demands are the following:  That from the date that you Marren received and withheld funds from my late brother Michael Gavin RIP and I, an interest rate of 8% is accruing to our account plus expenses, because of YOUR failure to make good on our legitimate claim or take the matter back to the courts for a Judge to decide.  The above has been written to and email to YOU Marren and your State Solicitor Peter D Jones numerous times, but no reply.

There is a charge against the properties of my late brother Patrick Gavin RIP with the  Land Registry, Roscommon. You do not have my permission to sell the house until such time as my above demands are met. 

Have you Robert B Marren informed those currently using the lands Michael Myers and Paddy Myers Dundonnell Taughmaconnell and Lawrence McManus Pettigo Donegal that the lands are in dispute and were obtained fraudulently?

Have you Robert B Marren informed YOUR CLIENTS Ann Sanford Wellesley Massachusetts, Kathleen O’Keeffe Glanmire, Cork, Patrick Duffy, Philomena Duffy Davitt College, Castlebar, Noel Duffy Athlone, Kathryn Kelly Duffy Portiuncula Hospital Ballinasloe, Michael J. Harte Wellesley Massachusetts, Michelle Harte, Brenda Waters Quincy USA of the impact this matter will have on them. What will their work colleagues, neighbours, and friends have to say???

Have you Robert B Marren informed the department of Agriculture and instruct them to stop paying out grants on the Farm lands until such time as this matter is sorted?

My brother Pat Gavin died intestate in October 2005. You Robert B Marren were appointed to administer the estate of my late brother. You Marren considered the other beneficiaries to be your clients, you favoured their wishes, followed their instructions and ignored my brother Michael Gavin RIP and my objections and that was the opinion from by Tony Watson from Law Society Ireland.

We did attempt to retain a solicitor Tony Henry Tormeys Solicitors Athlone, however he did NOT undertake the instructions given him through John Glynn and therefore YOU Marren closed the estate in isolation to our objections.

FOR THE RECORD. My brother Michael Gavin RIP was out of pocket in excess of €116,000 Department of Agriculture Grants.  Both my brother and I were shorted €12,500 EACH from Proceeds of the Land sale and a further €3,700 was deducted from me for cattle I never owned.

My demands remain the same from the date Robert B Marren received and withheld funds from my deceased brother Michael Gavin and I an interest rate of 8% per Month is accruing to the benefit of our accounts plus expenses because of Robert B Marrens failure to make good on our legitimate claim.

Here is the exact letter that was sent to you by my late brother Michael Gavin RIP and I when we responded to your previous request for our signatures on form 36 back in October 2017

Dear Mr Marren,

In response to your letter dated 24th October, 2017.

RE: House at Taughmaconnell

Paragraph 1 of your letter Mr. Marren you stated:

I refer to your recent correspondence regarding the above. I have received correspondence from Patrick Hogan & Company Solicitors on your behalf also.

My Response:

The recent correspondence you received from me personally contained 10 questions. Only the first 2 questions were in relation to “Houses at Taughmaconnell” Co. Roscommon.

I would be most grateful if you would stop coercing me into retaining a Solicitor and respond to each of my 10 questions in order.

You Robert Marren have NOT dealt with any of the issues raised in my letter in your response or your “previous correspondence” and I propose to pursue you vigorously until the matters are resolved to my satisfaction.

Paragraph 2 of your letter Mr. Marren you stated:

The Position is that Application is being made in the Land Registry to register the beneficiaries as owners of the house in which you currently reside, which belonged to your late brother Patrick Gavin deceased. I have circulated Land Registry Forms 36 which is required to be signed by each of the beneficiaries in order to achieve this. I forwarded a form for a signature by you to your Solicitor, whom you should consult in relation thereto. The registration of the beneficiaries as owners of the property does not affect your Right of Residence. You will still be entitled to reside there by law.

My Response

The above paragraph refers to Folio 9544F my current home and where I have lived most of my life with my brother Pat Gavin who died in October 2005 over 12 years ago.

I have a number of questions I would like you to answer with regard to the above 2nd paragraph of your letter Mr Robert B Marren.

  1. Why has it taken until now for you Robert B Marren to make application to Land Registry to register the beneficiaries as owners of the house in which I currently reside?
  2. Why did you LIE Robert B Marren to me in previous correspondence when you stated you had finished administrating the estate?
  3. Who Robert B Marren requires all the beneficiaries to sign Land Registry Forms 36?
  4. Why don’t you do the right thing and circulate a form requiring the beneficiaries to return what they ROBBED from me?
  5. Who is my Solicitor Robert B Marren?
  • John Glynn was asked to step aside by the Law Society of Ireland.
  • Tony Henry Tormeys Solicitors Athlone failed to undertake instructions.
  • Martin Egan informed me that because you are the son in law of Aidan O’Carroll I will not get representation in the midlands.
  • Barristers are looking for €30,000 cash upfront to sue you.

 

Paragraph 3 of your letter Mr. Marren you stated:

In relation to your query regarding the lands comprised in Folio RN36155F. Your Solicitor will explain that this piece of ground that was registered in the names of the original Administrators. When I was appointed Administrator by the High Court, I then registered the property in my name as Administrator. This piece of ground will also be registered in the names of the beneficiaries.

My Response

The above paragraph refers to Folio 36155F old historical home where I was born and reared.

A Solicitor has already explained irregularities to me with regard to Folio 36155F

 

I have a number of questions I would like you to answer with regard to the above 3rd  paragraph  of your letter Mr Robert B Marren.

 

  1. Why did you Robert B Marren registered Folio 36155F in your name as Administrator?
  2. Why was Folio 36155F excluded from the land sale?
  3. According to the Land Registry in Roscommon Folio 36155F was recently registered in the names of the beneficiaries. Why was/am I not required to complete FORM 36 for the Folio 36155F but I am required for Folio 9544F??

 

Paragraph 4 of your letter Mr. Marren you stated:

This is the final step in the administration of your late brother’s Estate and I hope to complete this as soon as all the Land Registry forms are signed by the beneficiaries to enable me proceed. Until I receive the necessary documentation duly signed, I cannot finalize matters.

My response

I suggest you chew on a recent statement made by an informed individual obviously familiar with my case of Financial Elder Abuse.

The feeling of injustice, of being wronged, can eat away at a man’s soul. It seems too that it is invariably the poor man who is on the receiving end: he has not the wherewithal either to take on the rich and privileged wrong-doers. No there is no justice for the poor. Law was after all invented in the ancient world by the rich and powerful specifically to oppress the poor… The poor wronged man will surely carry his sense of injustice with him into the grave. And there is not a thing he can do about it. ~ peter robinson

There is no doubt that I Michael Gavin will carry my sense of injustice with me into the grave. However how many generations of those rich and privileged wrong-doers will be haunted by their ancestral shame?

Paragraph 5 of your letter Mr. Marren you stated:

The other issues that you raised in your letter have been dealt with in previous correspondence and I do not propose to revisit the matters. The administration has been completed, save for the final step and I would be obliged if you would forward to me the documentation duly signed to enable me proceed.

My Response

No that is another LIE Robert B Marren the 10 questions below remain unanswered. I would be much obliged if you and the beneficiaries would return what you ROBBED from me.

Questions you refuse to answer.

Question 1

Re Folio RN36155F the old historical home where I was born and reared.

  1. Who authorised you Mr. Robert B Marren to register yourself as full owner?
  2. Who authorised you Mr. Robert B Marren to make application to Roscommon Land Registration Authority for applicants Ann Sanford Wellesley Massachusetts, Kathleen O’Keeffe Glanmire, Cork, Eileen Linney, Michael Gavin, Patrick Duffy, Philomena Duffy, Noel Duffy, Kathryn Kelly, Michael J. Harte, Michelle Harte, Brenda Waters as owners of Folio RN36155F.
  3. I was not required to complete FORM 36 for the above registration. WHY?

Question 2

Re Folio 9544F the home where I currently reside.

  1. Why are you a coercing me again to engage a solicitor at my expense to complete FORM 36.
  2. Why has it taken until now for you Mr. Robert B. Marren to deal with this vexatious issue bearing in mind that my brother Pat Gavin died in October 2005 over 12 years ago.
  3. Will I still be entitled to reside in my home as per my fathers will?

Question 3

Who authorised you Mr. Robert B. Marren to favour the wishes of my 2 devious and spiteful sisters Ann Sanford and Kathleen O’Keefe. According to Tony Watson of the Law Society of Ireland you followed their clear instructions. What about my valid objections Marren?

Question 4

Who authorised you Robert B. Marren to distribute the estate assets speedily over the Christmas period 2014 in the knowledge that myself and my sister Eileen Linney were actively attempting to retain a solicitor (Tony Henry Tormeys Solicitors Athlone) to act on our behalf to prevent you closing. Why didn’t you do the right thing and take the case back before a judge as I instructed you to do.

Question 5

Who authorised you Robert B. Marren to Delay making the decision regarding my share in the farming profits and rightful share of the grant monies received from the Department of Agriculture until the very end with the draft distribution account that contained countless errors on 18th September, 2014?

Question 6

Who authorised you Robert B. Marren, Solicitor, Mullingar to make a decision in March 2013 to accept my claim to owning half the livestock and all the sheep?

But yet for no logical reason you refused to award me the net amount €116,789.11 due to me out of the Single Payment Entitlements representing my ½ share in the profits from farming the lands, which was also sent to you Mr. Robert Marren, Solicitor, Mullingar on the 5th of December, 2015 for your consideration.

Question 7

Who authorised you Robert B. Marren to award me Elderly Michael Gavin and my widowed sister €12,500 plus interest less than what we were entitled to? Who authorised you to hold on to the funds from the land sale for nearly 2 years for no good reason?

Question 8

Who authorised you Robert B. Marren NOT to provide your detailed bill of costs as requested numerous times?

Question 9

Who authorised you Robert B. Marren to hire your own personal accountant Damien Hannigan & Company Limited Chartered Accountant, Mullingar. Why was he hired against the explicate wishes of Michael Gavin and Eileen Linney to oversee the accounts of Catherine O’Conner?

Damien Hannigan charged an excessive fee of €8,751.45 which is considered to be extremely expensive and an unnecessary expe++nse. Although he was hired to oversee the accounts his fee is in excess of Catherine O’Conner’s fee.

Why do you Robert B. Marren refused to provide the correct invoice for Catherine O’Conner. Her invoice states Total Amount Due €584.25 while Cash Account dated 18th July, 2014 “Fees paid to Catherine O’ Connor €6,857.25.”

Question 10

Who authorised you Robert B. Marren to seek William Penrose B.L opinion.  Despite our numerous written requests No Invoice for William Penrose B.L. or explanation of why his opinion was sought. Did you pay Willie Penrose and what for?

The Estate was charged €1,230 for Willie Penrose’s opinion but no invoice was provided despite repeated persistent written requests. We were informed that Willie Penrose TD BL has refused to the investigating Garda a statement in relation to this matter.

As I have advised you in previous correspondence from the date you received and have withheld funds from my widowed sister Eileen Linney and I an interest rate of 8% per Month is accruing to the benefit of our accounts plus expenses because of your failure to make good on our legitimate claim.

Here is a link to file that was sent to DPP https://goo.gl/ryaqsf

Your Sincerely,

Eileen Linney

 

 

Michael Gavin’s RIP Funeral Wishes were Ignored

MemorialCard-1

Kathleen O’Keefe                                                                                                              

Anne Sanford

c/o T & N McLynn Solicitors

Athlone,

Co. Westmeath

Date 22/06/2015

 

In response to your letter dated 12th June, 2015. You hope I am “keeping well” after what may I ask, after being abused by two very vengeful and spiteful sisters, who put the Estate of my late brother Patrick Gavin to enormous legal expense and whom I have no doubt would be prepared to waste my personal assets in further litigation given a chance.

Or perhaps you mean am I keeping well after your #HighCourt Special Summons where you sought to sell the roof over my head among other things.

“By notices in writing Kathleen ‘OKeefe, and Mary Theresa Harte have confirmed their desire to have the house and lands of the estate sold. Nicholas Duffy and his four children have also confirmed that they desire to have the property sold. It is also the wish of the Plaintiff that the property be sold.”

Bearing in mind that you and your Solicitor T & N McLynn were well aware that I was entitled to live in the home for the rest of my days per my father’s will which you were all furnished with a copy of. As I recall I was required to attend the high court on 3 separate days, the first of which you did not attend.

On the second day I was informed by my barrister Donal Keane B.L. that ye were in another room arguing amongst yerselves, and then finally we got before the judge on the third day. This is just one of the numerous examples of your vengeful, spiteful behaviour where you both squandered the Estate assets.

Or perhaps you mean am I keeping well after YOU FAIL to accept that I am entitled to half the farming profits (i.e. half the net proceeds of the Department of Agriculture Grants from 2005-2013 inclusive, after deduction of Income Tax paid in respect of the joint farming operation) and/or in the alternative, fair compensation for work done and services rendered by me in looking after the deceased’s animals over the period.

I am aware that the lease with #AnneSanford and yourself will end on the 31st July, 2015. I will ensure the land is cleared of all livestock as of that date as per your request. As far as I am concerned the lands are cursed and I have no intention of releasing or purchasing or having anything more to do with it.

As I recall you rushed me into signing your lease agreement on 27th August without providing me an opportunity to read over same carefully or to consider the matter. Consequently I was forced to get legal advice in order to amend a number of your conditions including my agreement to “having fully restored the lands to grassland by ploughing and reseeding by no later than the 31st of July 2015.” Lands that were never used for tillage, and even if they were who would commit to a short term 1 year lease with that condition.

t&n+front (1)

This appears underhanded to me and highlights the inadequate professional service provided by your Solicitor #T&NMcLynn, #Athlone. It is not of a quality that could reasonably be expected of a solicitor and severed no purpose other than to force me to incur additional unnecessary expenses for legal advice to draft letters in response to the lease agreement you tricked me into signing.

I would question also whether T&N McLynn is guilty of Misconduct by tending to bring the solicitors profession into disrepute. It is worth noting also that I was never provided a copy of your Solicitors T&N McLynn’s Bill of Costs.

Regardless it appears ye did not accept the 9 animals that remained on the lands (after closing) separately belong to me, as 50% of the value of the livestock handed over on closing of the sale is deducted from me on the revised distribution account dated 12th of November, 2014. I maintained that these animals were entirely my own animals, being the progeny of those animals listed as being my animals in the list prepared following the herd test on 28th of July, 2008. There is no other good reason as to why I would want a 1 year lease agreement other than to house and care for my own animals.

Around the time of the leasing I do recall expressing to you my dissatisfaction at not receiving any grant monies from the Department of Agriculture or monies for looking after my brother’s livestock on behalf of the Estate, and you lie by stating “it would be taken care of at closing”.

I also recall my sister Anne Sanford also lied by stating over the years that she would purchase nuts for the cattle, a cup of which I have yet to see.

I have many issues with the manner in which the Estate of my late brother Patrick Gavin was dealt with and the #LawSocietyofIreland has been informed in recent days.

Some of these issues include the following:

  1. I was not furnished with a copy of your Solicitor T & N McLynn’s Bill of Costs for the handsome fee of €38,941.00
  2. Marren’s persistent reluctance to provided me with his own detailed Bill of Cost to date for €40,892.53
  3. How the auction of the property was dealt with. The auction aborted and you the purchasers did not proceed with the purchase. Then you got the remaining of the next of kin, namely Theresa Harte, and the Duffy family to disclaim/release their shares in the deceased’s Estate;
  4. I have issues regarding how my objections prior to the Estate Accounts being finalised were dealt with against my wishes over the Christmas period;
  5. No Invoice for #JohnDolanAuctioneer and breakdown of the fee he was paid was provided to me to date. . As I recall the auctioneer John Dolan did advertise the auction extensively and I recall full and half page ads appeared in the local newspapers. I would argue that based on the amount of interest and bids made at the auction that these ads served no purpose other than to promote John Dolans Auctioneering service as a whole. To be honest a free mention in the local parish newsletter would have sufficed.
  6. #DamienHannigan & Company Limited Chartered Accountant, Mullingar were hired against my wishes to oversee the accounts of Catherine O’Conner. They charged in my opinion an excessive fee of €8,751.45 which I consider to be extremely expensive and an unnecessary expense. Although he was hired to oversee the accounts his fee is in excess of Catherine O’Conner fee;
  7. No invoice for #WilliamPenrose B.L. or explanation of why his opinion was sought was provided for bill of €1,230.00
  8. Why was I not awarded half of the Grant Money from the Department of Agriculture after a decision was made around March 2013 to accept my claim to owning half the livestock and all the sheep.

Etc..

After the death of my brother Patrick, I was appointed herd keeper for the animals by the Department of Agriculture. My understanding was that I would receive the grant monies paid from the department to subsidise the looking after the animals. As I recall I did receive some monies from John Glynn, Solicitor paid down from the department, and then later on Anne Sanford and yourself objected to this.

How can the estate expect to have it both ways, I feel I should be awarded either the grant monies paid by the Department of Agriculture for the nine years I looked after all the animals, or in the alternative I should be paid reasonable farm labors wages and refunds for the expenses incurred in running the farm as appointed herd keeper by the Department of Agriculture.

Anne Sanford, yourself and the next of kin namely #MikeHarte, #BrendaHarteWaters, #MichelleHarte, #PhilomenaDuffy, #PatrickDuffy, #CatherineDuffyKelly and #NoelDuffy cannot have it both ways. They cannot on the one hand expect to receive the monies from the sale of my late brother Pat Gavin’s livestock together with the gross payments received from the Department of Agriculture, without incurring any expense for the minding, looking after and caring for the animals down through the years.

Catherine O’Conner’s Account Summary 24/02/2012 shows that throughout the entire farming period between 2005 and 2012 the cattle sales came to a figure of €46,589 and the expenses came to a figure of €45,918. Accordingly, the expenses in running the farm were almost equal to the proceeds of sale of livestock. Therefore the profit from the farming operation represented the monies received each year from the Department of Agriculture under the single Payment Scheme, the Disadvantaged Area Scheme and any other Schemes of the Department of Agriculture, less any income tax payable to the state arising out of the farming operation.

I and those I have spoken to in relation to this matter FAIL to see the logic to your reluctance to see reason in this matter, how do you expect me to labor for free for 9 years at my own expense and pay vets fees and fodder to fatten cattle so that those that do nothing can reap the rewards of the GROSS profits. I believe with every bone in my body that I am entitled to be paid for the work done and services rendered and monies expended by me in looking after my brother’s livestock from the time my brother died up to the time the animals were sold, this you will appreciate involved the daily herding and looking after the animals to include feeding of the animals in Winter months to include purchase of food stuffs and discharging vets fees etc.

By denying me a half share in the profits it means that I WAS WORKING FOR NOTHING over the years in question from October, 2005 through to 2013. This is totally unjust and totally unacceptable to me.

I will not accept the present situation which is totally unfair and leave me without any compensation whatsoever for my time and trouble in looking after the animals on behalf of the estate and also deprives me of any profit I may have earned in the rearing and looking after my own animals.

Please find enclosed a detailed breakdown of the net amount €116,789.11 due to me out of the Single Payment Entitlements representing my ½ share in the profits from farming the lands, which was also sent to Mr. Marren, Solicitor, on the 5th of December, 2015 for your consideration. You will note that all I am looking for is my fair share of the profits in the running of the farm and fair compensation for the work I did in looking after the animals.

beneficiaries-11

I would advise each of you namely Anne Sanford, Kathleen O’Keefe, Mike Harte, Brenda Harte Waters, Michelle Harte, Philomena Duffy, Patrick Duffy, Catherine Duffy and Noel Duffy, if ye are not prepared to be reasonable in this matter there will be no alternative but to go back to Court again to have the matter determined.

If I do not have a favourable response back from you I intend instructing a Solicitor in this matter and taking such proceedings as are necessary against Anne Sanford, yourself and the next of kin namely Mike Harte, Brenda Harte Waters, Michelle Harte, Philomena Duffy, Patrick Duffy, Catherine Duffy Kelly and Noel Duffy to agree a fair allowance to me out of the Single Payment Entitlements representing my ½ share in the profits from farming the lands.

I hereby also put you on notice that I have made my funeral wishes known to Father #SeanNeylon, and Garda Tim Farrell, #Taughmaconnell that I do not want any of you in attendance at my funeral.

I would appreciate any further correspondence for me to be sent to my family Solicitor John Glynn, #Ballinasloe.

 

Yours faithfully

 

Michael Gavin

MemorialCard-4

cc

Dave Sanford , 31 Atwood Street, #Wellesley, #Massachusetts, 02482, U.S.A.

Dave O’Keefe 42 #Glancarn, #Glanmire, Co. #Cork.

Mike Harte, 8 Fells Road, Wellesley, Massachusette, 02482, U.S.A.

Ms. Michelle L. Harte, 95 Fountain Ln. Apt 7, #Weymouth, Mass 02190-2135

Phil Duffy 21 Summerfield, #Castlebar, Co. #Mayo.

Patrick Duffy Tarmon West, #Kilkee, Co. #Clare.

Catherine Duffy 4 Woodville Grove, Athlone, Co. #Westmeath.

Noel Duffy 4 Woodville Grange, Athlone, Co. Westmeath.

Brenda Harte Waters c/o 8 Fells Road, Wellesley, Massachusette, 02482, U.S.A.

Fr. Sean Neylon, Chapel Street, Taughmaconnell, Co. Roscommon.

Garda Tim Farrell, Taughmaconnell, Co. Roscommon.

#RobertBMarren & Co. Solicitors, Castle Street, Mullingar, Co. Westmeath.

Mr. Donal F. Keane B.L. Barrister at Law , Law Library, Four Courts, Dublin 7.

Cllr. Paddy Kilduff Glanduff, Kiltoom, Athlone, Co. Roscommon.

#CatherineOConner, Chartered Accountants, Dunlo Hill, Ballinasloe, Co. Galway.

John Dolan Auctioneers & Chartered Surveyors, Main St, Ballinasloe Co. Galway.

#WilliamPenrose B.L. Convent Lane, Bishop Gate Street, Mullingar, Co. Westmeath.

Damien Hannigan & Company Limited Chartered Accountant, 7 Oliver Plunkett Street, Mullingar, Co. Westmeath.

Mr. Simon Coveney T.D. Minister for Agriculture, Food & the Marine and Minister for Defence Agriculture House, Kildare St. Dublin 2.

Cllr. #DenisNaughton Monksland Business Park, Athlone, Co. Roscommon.

Fr John Newman, Parish Priest Glanmire Parish, Springhill, Glanmire, Co. Cork  086-8168668.

Rev. Kevin M. Sepe  Pastor, St. Paul Parish, 502 Washington Street Wellesley, MA 02482. U.S.A. 781-235-1060   Email:  stpaulsecretary@verizon.net.

Fr Declan Shannon, St Mary’s Presbytery, Athlone, Co. Westmeath 090 6472088 stmarysparishathlone@eircom.net.

Joe Duffy, #RTE Donnybrook, Dublin 4 1850-715815 joe@rte.ie.

Mr. Paul Finnegan, HSE CHO Area 2, Carolan House, Sacred Heart Hospital, Roscommon Tel: 090 6637833 Email: Paul.finnegan@hse.ie.

Against Denis Naughten’s Constitution to Represent Michael Gavin RIP Against Corrupt Greedy Solicitors

Denis Naughten

Against Denis Naughten's Constitution to Represent Michael Gavin RIP Against Corrupt Greedy Solicitors

 

Denis Naughten Letter

On Thu, Jul 30, 2015 at 11:02 AM, Denis Naughten <denis.naughten@oireachtas.ie> wrote:

Michael,
I’ve read you e-mails & blog and view your online video.
It is clear that you were very badly advised in the past not to have ensured that both you and your brother made a will to protect both sets of rights.
While there is no doubt that there are questions regarding the management of this case, the only way that these can be resolved and rectified is by the Courts.
In my 18 years in politics I have not nor will I become involved in family disputes of this nature because, in my experience, everybody loses and the only real winners are the barristers & their bank accounts.
I think that arbitration may have been useful at an earlier stage, but this ultimately is a dispute between the various beneficiaries of the will.
I’m sorry but I cannot be of assistance to you with regard to this matter.
I’m also sending a copy of this e-mail to your nephew, who has also made contact with me, on your behalf.
Yours sincerely,
Denis

#DenisNaughten TD

My Respone email as follows:

Denis,

Totally agree with you the only way that these can be resolved and rectified is by the Courts

However it was Mr. #RobertbMarren Solicitor the administrator for the Estate that should have taken the matter to the courts to have a Judge decide not demand the Elderly Beneficiaries to issue proceedings when there were objection.

#TonyHenry #TormeysSolicitors did nothing except sit on the files for 3 months. He was instructed by John Glynn Solicitor to write and phone Marren immediately to prevent him closing.

It appears that he too wanted to play God in the matter. Why if he was not prepared to act on our behalf did he not phone us and say so. A Solicitor not undertaken an instruction is a very very serious matter and many have been disciplined for same in the past according to the records on line which are referred to in the blog.

I doubt very much that Marren or Henry would work for nothing yet they appear to think that they have a right to play God in my case.

John Glynn helped us write many a letter to Marren on unheaded paper pointing out the fact that he should seek a court order to direct how the Estate should be Administrated.

Thank you for taking the time to read the blog!

However in view of the fact that you did, how can Marren holding on my 1/6 share and my sisters 1/6 share of the monies from the land sale for nearly 2 years be explained??

There is no good reason why Marren did not pay these monies to us when he received them!

What he did pay out in the end was €12,500 short of what we were entitled to plus interest with no acceptable explanation to date as to why he did same.

It appears he also refuses also to pay John Glynn the money he claims some €50k plus for his services…yet he had no issue paying T&N Mc lynn a year or so prior to closing.

Why do they continually scourge me with their petty battles, what has it got to do with me? and why does Marren threaten Eileen and I that he will not pay John Glynn bill while we seek justice through the law society. How are they related??

We are now told #WilliePenrose was not paid, not that we were ever given an invoice for his services, but Marren did deduct for it.

Eileen and i never met with Penrose and we only met with Marren once and all he wanted to discuss was us making our wills….what had that got to do with the Administration of my late brothers Estate, or what business was it of his anyway whether we had our will made or not.

It would appear that because Marren is the Son in Law of #AidanOCarroll a prominent retired #Solicitor in #Athlone that none of the Solicitors in the Midland are prepared to act on our behalf.

However we intend to expose the #INJUSTICE and #ELDERABUSE we have been subjected too in the public domain and thereby encourage more in our situation to stand up to the Bully Boy tactics lies and deceit that our justice system is riddled with.

I am 83 year of age and I do not deserve to be treated in this fashion. I have worked hard all my life and never wronged any man and if a pair of white bellied bast***S think they can take advantage of my Elder Widowed sister and I they have another thing coming.

Did you have a chance to read the repulsive letter Tony Henry of Tormeys Solicitor sent to Eileen yesterday(copy attached), we were deprived of sleep and up half the night scribbling a response to same. They call them selves educated and he had the cheek to  criticizes my signature, what has he a scratch of a line get more from a 2 year old, at least mine spells out my GOOD name.

Tony-Henry-Tormeys-Solicitors-Signature

We are not satisfied with the service on offer in this country to deal with this Injustice and Elder Abuse and as far as we are concerned a country that does not look after its Elderly is no country. To date the only real sympathy and support we have received is from the ordinary people while the rest of yea pluck out one excuse or another as to why yea cannot or do not help out in these matters. Well yea wont sweep this under the carpet and hide away from the facts we have copies of all the correspondence and recall  what went on.

Have a nice day!

Michael Gavin

DenisNaughten3

Denis Naughten TD Meeting

Denis Naughten TD met with Eileen Linney, Mike Gavins sister in #GulliansHotel on Friday 19th June 2016 after 10:30am. He stated he did not get involved in family disputes as its against the constitution. Eileen explained what was owed to her brother Mike Gavin and herself and gave details of the amount due to Mike Gavin for his work done over a 9 year period. She explain that she did not own any cattle yet there was €3,700 deducted from her share plus €12,500 from the land sale , a further €116,000 plus €12,500 from the land sale was deducted for her brother Mike Gavin  by Robert B. Marren Solicitor.

Denis Naughten TD stated for them to get a Solicitor and write to the Supreme Court – #SusanDenham. Eileen stated Robert Marren was appointed to administer the estate which he didn’t do and Denis Naughton stated the Judge who appointed him would have agreed with what he did. Denis also stated he did not like the information on Twitter about himself and or #RobertTroy.

End of Meeting

Well Denis we don’t like the fact that you did nothing for us. How come it was Clare Daly TD who attempted to question Tanaiste and Minster for Justice re #Roscommon #Gardai entering Elderly Mike Gavin’s Home? Where were you Denis Naughton TD. As for twitter don’t you recall you blocked @michaelgavin83 as did #RobertToryTD, although Troy did go on to sign one of Mike Gavin’s petitions on the day of voting.

Our justice system is repeatedly and systematically failing us. Worse than that, it seams that many of those in exalted positions of authority such as yourself Denis Naughten TD, Robert Troy TD, #WilliePenroseTD, Tony Henry Tormeys Solicitors Athlone,  #TonyMcLynn T&N Mc Lynn Solicitors Athlone, Robert B. Marren Solicitor Mullingar, #PeterDJones State Solicitor #Mullingar and the #LawSocietyofIreland are greatly abusing our trust. It would appear that in #Ireland if the perpetrators are in any way “connected” then our justice system is far more likely to throw up a wall of protection and denials around them.

Don’t be surprise if a peaceful assembly protest arrives at your door in the coming days to express dissatisfaction at the Job your not doing

Have a Nice Day!

Against the constitution to stand up to Solicitors Corruption and Financial Elder Abuse DENIS NAUGHTEN??

  1. Robert Marren Solicitor refused to award Michael Gavin the grant money’s paid down from the Dept. of Agriculture. Michael is owed over €116,000 for 9 years minding the farm Animals.
  1. Robert Marren Solicitor held onto the funds from the land sale for nearly 2 years, and then finally awarded to Michael Gavin and his sister €12,500 plus interest less than what we were each entitled to.
  1. Willie Penrose TD BL was not paid for his opinion, when the estate was charged for same.
  1. Robert Marren Solicitor Squandered the estate assets and hired an additional accountant at a cost of €8,751.45.
  1. Marren did not provide a “detailed bill of costs” for his fee of €40,892.53 he awarded to himself.
  1. No bill of costs was provided for T & N McLynn Solicitors, Athlone, paid an amount of €38,941 a year prior to closing.
  1. Tony Henry, Tormeys Solicitors, Athlone failed to undertake the instructions given him through John Glynn Solicitors to prevent Mr. Robert Marren closing in isolation to well founded objections.

To commit fraud is an offense in Ireland. But the prosecution will depend very much on where you reside on the social scale!

noballs

Peter Jones is the #FiannaFail appointed State #Solicitor for #Westmeath. He is now more than 2 decades in this position. Peter Jones is a right wing conservative on moral issues and he has been against every piece of reformist referenda for decades, including the Divorce Referendum of 1995. Only a few years ago, Peter Jones had 8 #PENALTY POINTS corruptly and illegally removed, a matter which appeared in the Phoenix Magazine at the time. Peter Jones is now threatening an 83 year old farmer. Is it not enough for 83 year old Mike Gavin to have been defrauded of a large sum of money by Mr. Jones’s friend and fellow Mullingar solicitor Robert Marron? Is there nothing so low as to what the legal profession in Mullingar will stoop to? Just as you thought that they could not sink any lower by defrauding an elderly farmer, they are now threatening him.

Gardai=Harrased-Michael-Gavin-RIP

Gardai Interrogate Elderly Mike Gavin in his home

On Friday the 20th of May a local Garda and #Roscommon detective called to Mike Gavin’s Home, Dundonnell #Taughmaconnell. They were told Mikie was gone to Mullingar (Protest). They said they wanted to see Mikie re the #Fraud “Thing”.

They called back the next day despite the fact that Mike’s sister Eileen called them and told them that they were sending their Fraud file to Dublin when it was complete.
They came regardless and told Mike’s sister it had nothing to do with her and they wanted to see Mike Gavin. Mike’s sister locked the door and told them repeatedly out the window to go away and leave them alone and eventually they did.
3 Gardai returned Wednesday when and got Mike home alone. Mike Gavin describes here what happened.
Share and Expose the Blue Bully Boys working for Peter D. Jones

New Year Resolutions

allcomplicit2 - Copy

My new years resolution is to expose each and every one of them because if we don’t their children will rob our children.

Currently I am receiving threatening phone calls from a person by the name of Lawrence McManus from Pettigo, Co. Donegal Mobile No 083 113 3608. He claims to be an appointed mediator. He is currently using the farm lands at Dundonnell. He has phoned me demanding the keys to the house and states by law he has the rights to the keys. He stated that he intends to sell the home in March 2019. He claimed to local person in a recorded phone conversation that all the family are in agreement to sell the home and he has filed signed agreement with the district courts. This is a lie as I did not sign any agreement with Lawrence McManus nor did I meet with him.

Their Solicitor Robert B Marren has ignored us numerous times when my late brother and I informed him that

We have also written the following to Marren and his Solicitor Peter D Jones and he has ignored us too.

I demand that you provide documentary evidence of the following:

  1. Invoice for Willie Penrose’s TD fee that the estate was charged for.
  2. Proof that Willie Penrose TD BL was in fact paid for his opinion.
  3. Correct invoice for Catherine O’Connor.
  4. Proof that you Robert B. Marren received €165,000 from Anne Sanford and Kathleen O’Keefe through their solicitor Tony Mc Lynn of T & N McLynn Solicitors Athlone to cover Michael Gavin and Eileen Linney’s 1/6 share from the land sale.
  5. Invoice for John Dolan Auctioneer Ballinasloe, Co. Galway
  6. Detailed bill of costs for your fee Robert B. Marren
  7. Detailed Bill of costs for T&N McLynn solicitors Athlone.

Provide answers to the following:

  1. Why Did you Robert B. Marren refuse to award Michael Gavin the grant money paid down from the dept. of Agriculture? I Mike Gavin am owed over €116,000 for 9 Years unpaid.
  2. Why did you Robert B. Marren hold on to the funds from the land sale for nearly 2 years?
  3. Why did you Robert B. Marren award me Elderly Michael Gavin and my widowed sister €12,500 plus interest less than what they were entitled to?
  4. Why did you Robert B. Marren deduct €3,500 from Eileen Linney for Animals she never owned?
  5. Why was no invoice provided for William Penrose’s TD BL opinion?
  6. Why did you Robert B. Marren hire an additional accountant Damien Hannigan 7 Oliver Plunkett St. Mullingar at a cost of €8,751.45 to oversee the Accounts?
  7. Why did you Robert B. Marren not provide the correct invoice for Accountant Catherine O’Connor?
  8. Why did you Mr. Robert B. Marren not provide a “Detailed Bill of Costs” for your fee of €40,892.53 you awarded to yourself?
  9. Why did you Robert B. Marren Solicitor consider the other beneficiaries to be your clients?
  10. Why did you Robert B. Marren distribute the estate assets in isolation to well-founded objections?
  11. Why did you Robert B. Marren refuse to take the well-founded objection to a Judge?
  12. Why did you Robert B. Marren threaten 2 of the elderly beneficiaries and coerce them to retain a solicitor to prevent you distributing the estate assets?
  13. Why did you Robert B. Marren distribute the estate assets speedily over the Christmas period 2014 in the knowledge that 2 of the beneficiaries were actively attempting to retain a solicitor to act on their behalf?
  14. Why did Tony Henry Tormeys Solicitors Athlone fail to undertake the instructions given him through John Glynn Solicitors to prevent you Mr. Robert Marren closing in isolation to well-founded objections?
  15. Why did T & N McLynn Solicitors, Athlone summon (special)me Mike Gavin and Eileen Linney to the High Court attempting to sell my home along with the farm and failed after three days squandering estate assets with fees in the High Court?      https://youtu.be/5xc4szyymjY
  16. Why was no bill of costs provided for T & N McLynn Solicitors, Athlone, paid an amount of €38,941 a year prior to the distribution of the estate assets?
  17. Why do you Robert Marren refuse to provide answers to these and other questions?
  18. Why Have you Robert B. Marren retained Peter D. Jones  Mullingar State Solicitor to represent you?
  19. Why does Peter D. Jones THREATEN me Elderly Michael Gavin Not to PEACEFUL Protest outside your Solicitors Office?
  20. Why should we tolerate Financial Elder Abuse?

As I have advised you in previous correspondence from the date you received and have withheld funds from my widowed sister Eileen Linney and I an interest rate of 8% per Month is accruing to the benefit of our accounts plus expenses because of your failure to make good on our legitimate claim.

This File given to Garda Fraud

https://t.co/4aZSZCUA9N

Pdf of Financial Elder Abuse Book

https://goo.gl/yDWCaQ

 

 

 

 

 

Francis-Fitzgerald

Minister Frances Fitzgerald Ignores Solicitors Financial Elder Abuse Why

 

Minister’s Reference 0531102449

Date 08/03/2017

Dear Minister Fitzgerald,

In response to your recent email dated 3rd March 2017, relating to the correspondence I emailed to your office dated June 10th 2016 I wish to state the following.
I appreciate the fact that you requested a Garda report to fully address my concerns, and fully trained investigators have since investigated the allegations I made and referred a file to the Director of Prosecutions (DPP).

However this further squandering of Tax Payers money could all have been avoided;

If Sean O Fearghail Ceann Comhairle allowed Clare Daly TD to question you Tanaiste and Minister for Justice and Equality re the legal grounds upon which members of An Garda Siochana in County Roscommon entered my home on 20th May 2016.

The written reason given to Clare Daly TD was “The question is not in order as it requires an interpretation of the law and relates not to a policy issue but to an individual case which is an operational one for An Garda Siochana. Begs the question who ordered this Garda operation bearing in mind that you Minister Fitzgerald requested a Garda report after you received my correspondence dated 10th June 2016.

If Robert B Marren Solicitor had performed his duties as appointed by Judge Mary Laffoy to administer the Estate of my Late Brother Patrick Gavin. Marren followed the clear instructions of the other beneficiaries, as stated by Tony Watson Solicitor Law Society of Ireland.

If Robert B Marren had not deprived me the right to have my well-founded objections brought before a Judge. Marren confiscated the Department of Agriculture grants, so I was tricked into working for nothing for over 9 years minding farm animals. My widowed sister and I were also shorted €12,500 plus interest from the sale of the lands at auction, not to mention money that was deducted from my sister for cattle she never owned any cattle in her life.

If Tony Henry Tormeys Solicitors Athlone had undertaken the written and verbal instructions given him though another solicitor to take proceedings against Marren and make him go before a Judge to address my valid objections instead of playing GOD in the matter.

If Tony Watson Law Society of Ireland had reprimanded Marren and Henry. Instead Watson threatened to block my email correspondence when I questioned whether Willie Penrose TD was paid for his opinion. No invoice to date has being provided for Penrose although the estate of my late Brother was charged. I very much doubt Penrose had much if anything to say for himself to the trained fraud investigator who questioned him.

If Peter D. Jones Westmeath State Solicitor (minus his penalty points) had responded to the correspondence on behalf of his client Robert B Marren. Jones threatened me not to peaceful protest outside his client Marren’s office. Coincidentally the Garda Fraud squad missed getting me home the first time they called unannounced as I was already on the road to peaceful assembly protest outside Marren and Jones offices in Mullingar.

If Linda Kirwan Solicitor from the Society of Ireland fit her purpose and reprimanded Penalty Points Jones State Solicitor for failing to answer the 20 questions I posed to him in regard to his client Robert B Marren’s administration of my late brother’s estate. Kirwan although she did send literature stating that by law a solicitor must provide a bill of costs to his client, she fails to enforce this law.

While I do understand that you as Tanaiste have no role in the investigation, prosecution or trail, I find it difficult to appreciate how the State funded Director of Prosecutions (DPP) can be considered an independent body.

Francis Fitzgerald Protest

Although I have no background or understanding of the common or statute laws that the DPP will use to base their decision on. I do understand what the old people meant when they said “The Law is as straight as a door jamb, it’s those that implements it thats crooked.” No man has a right to blaggard another the way them solicitors named above did me.

In the event that the DPP does not prosecute and bearing in mind the fact that solicitors generally refuse to challenge each other in cases such as mine.

What course of action is available to prevent Financial Elder Abuse??

Michael Gavin

Letter from Law Society Threatening to Block my email address 12-August-2015

Sign the petition

Please Support Michael Gavin Elderly 83 Year Old Irish Farmer by Signing Petition

Our Ref: 22942/l/19/7 and 22943/L/19/7

Dear Mr Gavin,

Despite the fact that both the above enquiry files have been closed, I continue to receive letters and email from you. I refer in particular to your letter of 26 July, and also you lengthy email of 30 July 2015.

You have referred one of these matters to the Independent Adjudicator, and I believe that she has upheld the Society’s decision to reject your complaint. In the circumstances, there is little point in you sending further correspondence and emails to me, as such further correspondence will not receive a reply. Indeed, if you continue to send emails to the Society, I will have no alternative but to block your email address. I do hope that that will not prove necessary.

Your sincerely

Tony Watson

Solicitor

Deputy Head of Complaints and Clients Relations Section

Fax 01 879 8785 email complaints@lawsociety.ie

My Response to above

I would argue that although the files are closed that my letter of 26 July, 2015 provides addition crucial evidence against the manner in which Mr. Robert Marren administered the Estate.

I still have difficulty understanding how your investigations did not find fault with the following:

  1. Why was Willie Penrose TD BL not paid for his opinion when the Estate was charged for same?
  2. Why was John Glynn Solicitor not paid? Read Letter to Mr. Marren
  3. Why did Robert Marren Solicitor Mullingar refuse to award me Michael Gavin the Grant monies paid down from the Department of Agriculture?
  4. Why did Robert Marren Solicitor Mullingar refuse to pay me for time spent and services rendered in looking after the Estate animals?
  5. Why did T & N McLynn summon me to the high court in an attempt to sell the roof over my head? knowing full well I had the right to reside there for the rest of my days as per my father’s Will.
  6. Why did Robert Marren Solicitor Mullingar refuse to pay my sister and I the monies from the Auction of the lands immediately?
  7. Why did Robert Marren Solicitor Mullingar pay us €12,500 each less than what we were due for the Land sale?
  8. Why did Robert Marren Solicitor Mullingar not go back to court when there were objections from the beneficiaries that could not be dealt with?
  9. Why did Tony Henry Tormeys Solicitors Athlone not undertake the instructions given him by a Solicitor to prevent Marren closing in isolation to our well founded objections?
  10. Why was an additional accountant hired?
  11. Why did Tony Henry Tormeys Solicitors Athlone write the letter he did to my sister Eileen?
  12. Why has Mr. Marren not provided a “detailed Bill of Costs” for the fees paid to him as he stated he would.
  13. follow this link Bones of Contention for more.

My lengthy email of 30 July 2015  was in response to Mr. Henry of Tormeys Solicitors letter  to my Elderly Defenseless Widowed sister Eileen Linney, who was only seeking justice through your office. Regardless of your findings, Mr. Henry had no right to scribe the letter that he did and his letter is just another example of his inadequate professional service that is not of a quality that could reasonably be expected of a solicitor and in my opinion he is guilty of misconduct by tending to bring the solicitors profession into disrepute. As I have stated before I have every intention of pursuing justice in this mater and will leave no stone unturned until same is forthcoming. Your threat to block my emails will not quench the truth of what occurred and I believe it an immature approach for a man in your position “Deputy Head of Complaints and Clients Relations Section” to adopt. I do hope you will come to your senses in this matter.

Have a Nice Day

Michael Gavin

@MichaelGavin83

Sign the petition

Please Support Michael Gavin Elderly 83 Year Old Irish Farmer by Signing Petition

Siobhan

It is so nice to see a member of the legal professional acting like a spoilt brat throwing his dummy out of the pram. Bet he stamps his feet too. What a disgrace to a distinguished profession. I’ll bet they are so proud to be associated with someone of his level.”

pmac

TBK

TBK-2

ANDORO

facebook-logo

Twitter-icon

tableofcontents

Please Support Michael Gavin Elderly 83 Year Old Irish Farmer by Signing Petition

Robert Troy Re-tweet

Sign the petition

Please Support Michael Gavin Elderly 83 Year Old Irish Farmer by Signing Petition

RobertTroy-2

Robert your Re-Tweet speaks volumes thank you for your support for my campaign for #Justice that originally started on July 8, 2015 when I was informed that Mr. Robert Marren, Solicitor your neighbor on Castle Street Mullingar refused to pay our family Solicitor his fee while we threaten to seek Justice through the law Society as he put it. Please click on this link to view our response to Mr. Rober Marren’s refusal to pay the fee of our family Solicitor and I believe you will get an idea of what we are dealing with.

While I do appreciate your offer to come to your office in Athlone to discuses the matter, I fail to see what use it would serve.

You see I believe with every bone in my body that a grave injustice has been served to my elder sister Eileen and I (83 years old) at the hands of the beneficiaries of the Estate and the Solicitors namely Robert Marren,  Tony Henry Tormeys Solicitors, Athlone and T & N McLynn Solicitors, Athlone.

I believe that it is they that need to meet with you and explain their reason for treating my sister and I in the manner that they did.

There are numerous issues that need explaining including the following;

  1. Why was Willie Penrose TD BL not paid for his opinion when the Estate was charged for same?
  2. Why did Robert Marren Solicitor Mullingar refuse to award me Michael Gavin the Grant monies paid down from the Department of Agriculture?
  3. Why did Robert Marren Solicitor Mullingar refuse to pay me for time spent and services rendered in looking after the Estate animals?
  4. Why did T & N McLynn summon me to the high court in an attempt to sell the roof over my head?
  5. Why did Robert Marren Solicitor Mullingar refuse to pay my sister and I the monies from the Auction of the lands immediately?
  6. Why did Robert Marren Solicitor Mullingar pay us €12,500 each less that what we were due for the Land sale?
  7. Why did Robert Marren Solicitor Mullingar not go back to court when there were objections from the beneficiaries that could not be dealt with?
  8. Why did Tony Henry Tormeys Solicitors Athlone not undertake the instructions given him by a Solicitor to prevent Marren closing in isolation to our well founded objections?
  9. Why was an additional accountant hired?
  10. Why did Tony Henry Tormeys Solicitors Athlone write the letter he did to my sister Eileen?
  11. follow this link Bones of Contention for more.

I feel that the greatest help you can be to me at this time is to condemn this behavior which constitutes #ElderAbuse

Sign the petition

Please Support Michael Gavin Elderly 83 Year Old Irish Farmer by Signing Petition

 

Have a Nice Day

Michael Gavin

@michaelgavin83

 

facebook-logo

 

Twitter-icon

Please Support Michael Gavin Elderly 83 Year Old Irish Farmer by Signing Petition

Support Michael Gavin’s Fight for Justice

Sign the petition

Please Support Michael Gavin Elderly 83 Year Old Irish Farmer by Signing Petition

Thank you for taking the time to read my story and that in itself is a tremendous support!

Although what has gone on over the last 10 years is a source of embarrassment for me, I feel that in order to STOP this occurring behind closed doors we need to share it. In the words of Benjamin Franklin

“Justice will not be served until those who are unaffected are as outraged as those who are.”

Spread my story Wide & Far with all yours friends and beyond. Tweet & RT on twitter Share on Facebook, email all your friends

If you wish email marrensolrs@eircom.net, thenry@tormeys.ie,complaints@lawsociety.ie and express your dissatisfaction at what has occurred in this matter.

email-to

“To Whom it may concern,

I hereby inform you of the following

Inadequate professional service have been provided by Mr Marren, Solicitor and Tony Henry Tormeys Solicitors Athlone  to Michael Gavin & his Sister Eilenn and in my opinion it is not of a quality that could reasonably be expected of a solicitor.

It would appear that Robert Marren Solicitor the Administrator for the Estate of Patrick Gavin refused to compensate Michael Gavin for the 9 years Michael spent minding the Estate Animals and withheld the Grant monies paid down from the Department of Agriculture.

It also appear that Mr Marren did not pay Michael & Eileen their share of the monies from the land Auction and held on to it for nearly 2 years.

It appears that when he did finally pay out the monies for the land auction they were €12,500 less than the amounts due each to them plus interest from the date when Mr. Marren Solicitor received same.

It would appear that Estate assets were squandered

It would appear that Tony Henry of Tormeys Solicitors did not undertake the instructions given him through the family Solicitor to intervene in the matter and contact Mr Marren immediately to prevent him closing in isolation to Objections made by Michael Gavin. Nor did Tony Henry Tormeys Solicitors let it be known that he would not undertake the instruction so another Solicitor could be hired.

It would also appear that there are many unanswered questions that Michael & Eileen are entitled to answers to.

I condemn this type of behaviour. It constitutes Bulling and  Elder Abuse of the highest order and will not go unnoticed.

Your Sincerely

Mr. Concerned that this is permitted to go on! ”

From Tuesday 1st September 2015

Volunteer to peacefully hand out information leaflet outside the offices of

Robert B. Marren
Address: Castle St, Mullingar, Co. Westmeath
Phone:(044) 934 3826
Email marrensolrs@eircom.net

Tony Henry Tormeys Solicitors
Address: Castle St, Athlone, Co. Westmeath
Phone:(090) 649 3456
Email thenry@tormeys.ie
tony-henry-intro

T & N McLynn
Address: 11/13 Bastion Court Connaught Street Athlone
Phone:(090) 649 8264

Place information on notice boards in your local area thoughout the universe.

e5a62f0d9991a261fa0a2ff51b1124ea

Shocking corruption exposed by elderly farmer. This is rural Ireland 2015. You won’t see it on 6.01 News. Read here: https://michaelgavindundonnell.wordpress.com/

Mike Gavin Dundonnell Page

Thank You

Michael Gavin

@michaelgavin83

Sign the petition

Please Support Michael Gavin Elderly 83 Year Old Irish Farmer by Signing Petition

DSC05477DSC05503poster33

Please Support Michael Gavin Elderly 83 Year Old Irish Farmer by Signing Petition

tableofcontents

Chain of Events

Sign the petition

Please Support Michael Gavin Elderly 83 Year Old Irish Farmer by Signing Petition

Hello, thank you for visiting my blog. My name is Michael Gavin of Dundonnell, Taughmaconnell, Ballinasloe, Co. Roscommon, Farmer, Bachelor, born in 1932 and currently aged 83 years.

I stand over all the information in this website and affirm it to be the whole truth and nothing but the truth. It records events that took place since my brother Pat Gavin died Intestate on the 10th of October, 2005 some 10 years ago. If you have further questions or need clarification of some of the material contained in this document feel free to contact me, all are welcome.

The information here covers issues arising in the administration of the said Estate by Robert Marren, Solicitor, the Administrator thereof, involving:-

  1. Payments out to me Michael Gavin and my sister Eileen of our shares of the gross proceeds of the deceased’s lands by the Administrator, Robert Marren.
  2. The question of making due and fair provision in the distribution of the cash assets in the Estate for the profits earned by myself Michael Gavin in the rearing of my own and the also the Estates livestock on the lands and/ or in the alternative, making fair allowance to me for work done and services rendered, by me in looking after the deceased’s livestock on the lands for the past 9/10 years since the deceased’s death on the 10th of October, 2005.

Following Pat’s death I Michael Gavin continued on farming the lands and caring for the livestock in exactly the same way as I had done for upward of 40 years previously, in the expectation that I would be allowed continue doing so by the rest of the family. However this was not possible, owing to the enmity between Ann Sanford and Kathleen O’Keeffe towards my sister Eileen and I. Ultimately I was forced to sell off the livestock and surrender the lands for the sale in due course of administration of the Estate.

I was obliged to use my own funds to fund the expenses of running the farm. Catherine O’Connor’s Account Summary shows that throughout the entire farming period between 2005 and 2012 the cattle sales came to a figure of €46,589 and the expenses came to a figure of €45,918. Accourdingly, the expenses in running the farm were almost equal to the proceeds of the sale of the livestock. Therefore, the profits from running the farming operation represented the monies received each year from the Department of Agriculture.

After the Grant of Administration was issued to Mr. Marren in July, 2012 he put pressure on me to sell the stock and make the lands available for sale. Notwithstanding my reluctance to give up farming, I did cooperate with him and accounted for the sale of the animals.

Ultimately the entire lands were offered for sale by public auction on 22nd of February, 2013. The dwelling house which they previously sought to have included in the sale, were excluded from the sale. I tried to buy the lands from the Estate prior to the Auction but they refused and ultimately Anne Sanford bid higher than me at the Auction. It would appear that the price that Anne Sanford and Kathleen O’Keeffe agreed to pay to purchase the lands was a gross overvaluation of the lands having regard to the nature, quality and condition of the lands at the time of purchase on 22nd February, 2013. Both Anne Sanford and Kathleen O’Keeffe subsequently visited me a number of times requesting that I purchase the lands for their winning bid price which I refused to do stating they had paid over one hundred thousand euros too much for the land. In or around the beginning of May, 2013 Kathleen O’Keeffe telephoned me advising that the lands were to be put up again for sale and that I Michael Gavin was to have a first option to purchase same. However, this did not take place and instead, it would appear that Anne Sanford and Kathleen O’Keeffe got the next of kin, namely Theresa Harte, and the Duffy family disclaim/release their shares in the deceased’s Estate to them, so that effectively, they could put forward a proposal to simply buy out my sister Eileen’s 1/6th and my 1/6th share in the property at the value of the property as determined at the Auction. Allowance were made for them to do the same on the condition that the total 1/6th share would be paid forthwith and that the costs of the incidental to the sale to include all Solicitors fees, Auctioneers fees and Engineers fees would be discharged solely by the Purchasers at their own expense and that I Michael Gavin be allowed have the use of the lands for the rest of my natural life, without interference from the Purchasers.

*14/03/2013 Marren to Gavin confirming that he had made a decision to accept the claim of Michael Gavin to ownership of half the cattle and all the sheep and confirming that the accounts would be prepared by Catherine O’Connor and approved by the Independent Accountant and accepted liability and also seeking a refund of the sum of €4,000 deducted by Michael Gavin on behalf of Feely Stone, Boyle on the basis that he was under the impression Michael Gavin was paid twice for this amount and also seeking payment for half the remaining livestock on the lands;

On 14th March 2013 received a letter from Mr Robert Marren of Robert B. Marren & Co. Solicitors stating in the third paragraph

“Having consider matters, I have made a decision that I will accept the claim of Michael that he owns half the livestock and all the sheep. The Accounts as prepare by Catherine O’Connor and approved by the Independent Accountant will be accepted on that basis. This will enable the Estate to finalize the Income Tax liability which needs to be done as soon as possible.”

Yet Mr Marren Solicitor refuses to award me Michael Gavin his share of the grants paid down from the Department of Agriculture.

In my response letter to Mr Marren on 28th March 2013 I stated in the fourth paragraph

“Finally, as the farming operation between me and my late brother, Patrick was a joint operation on the basis that we shared everything, I also require payment of half the proceeds of the single Payment Entitlements and Disadvantaged Area Grants paid or payable by the Department of Agriculture in respect of the lands be paid to me in return for the services rendered by me on behalf of the Estate in looking after both the deceased and my own animals and which sum would also represent the profit which I would derive from farming the lands on a 50/50 basis, as otherwise I would have been wasting my time looking after my late brother’s animals or in having and maintaining my own animals on the lands. I consider that this is an unreasonable request for settlement of this matter as if I proceed in the alternative on the basis of a claim for work done and services rendered under The Agricultural Wages Act I would be entitle to a far greater sum of monies than I am now seeking.”

28-03-2013 Gavin to Marren pointing out that the sum of €4,000 had not been deductrd by Mr. Glynn, Solicitor in respect of the amount due to Messrs. Feehily Stone, Boyle and also requesting that if his sisters were prepared to let the lands to him at a reasonable price that he would be prepared purchase the remaining animals from the Estate and finally, seeking payment of half the Single Payment Entitlements on the basis that these payments represented the profits from farming the lands, that he was entitled to 50% of same;

**05/07/13 Marron to Gavin and Linney enclosing copy letter dated 3rd of July, 2013 from T & N McLynn, Solicitors on behalf of Sanford and O’Keefe stating that purchasers were prepared to discharge Messrs Gavin & Linney’s share of the expenses in connection with the sale and confirming that their clients were not prepared to take up Michael Gavin’s offer to purchase;

05/12/14 Michael Gavin to Marren & Co., in reply to their letter of the 11th of November, incorporating claim of Michael Gavin to half Single Payment Entitlements, after deductions of Income Tax paid by the Estate on farming income, together with claim for payment of half agricultural wages due to Michael Gavin for minding the deceased’s livestock from 10th of October, 2005 to 27th of May, 2013, less allowances for half letting value of lands, together with the following:

  1. Schedule incorporating particulars of claim;
  2. Schedule of wages due under the Statutory Minimum Remuneration of Agriculture Workers for the period from 10/10/99 to 27/05/13

05/12/14 Marren & Co., to Michael Gavin advising that unless he was in receipt of legal proceedings instituted before the 19th of December, he intended to proceed with the distribution of the Estate;

22/12/14 Marren to Gavin threatening that unless he heard from Gavin’s Solicitor by 16th of January, next that Mr. Gavin intended to institute proceedings, that he would precede with the proposed distribution, as previously advised.

***14/01/2015 John Glynn Patrick Hogan & Co. to Tony Henry Tormeys Solicitors, Athlone requesting him to ring and write a short letter to Mr. Marren immediately confirming that he would act in the matter in response to Marrens threat to effect a distribution of the Estate.

06/02/2015 Eileen Linney and Michael Gavin to Tony Henry Tormey Solicitors Athlone instructing him to write a letter to Mr. Marren requesting answers to 7 questions;

He never did!

 29-July-2015 Letter from Tony Henry Tormeys Solicitors Athlone to Eileen Linney

12/08/2015 Letter from Law Society Threatening to Block my email address

Letter to An Garda Síochána

to be continued…….The Shame of Ireland

Sign the petition

Please Support Michael Gavin Elderly 83 Year Old Irish Farmer by Signing Petition

Letter to Justice Mary Laffoy

Sign the petition

Please Support Michael Gavin Elderly 83 Year Old Irish Farmer by Signing Petition

Dear Justice Mary Laffoy,

I am writing to give you to inform you of what happened after my special summons to the High court 9th of March , 2010. In the matter of the Estate of Patrick Gavin between Ann Sanford plaintiff and Eileen Linney and Michael Gavin defendants.

I am not satisfied with the manner in which the administration of the Estate was conducted by Robert Marren, Solicitor, Mullingar and I refer you to the enclosed documents which were sent to Mr. Tony Watson, Solicitor, Deputy Head of Complaints and Client Relations Section at Law Society of Ireland. Ref: 22942/L/19/7

I also have issues with Tony Henry, Tormeys Solicitors, Athlone for not undertaking the written and verbal instructions that were given him by another Solicitor on my behalf, namely to ring and or write Mr. Robert Marren, Solicitor, Mullingar. Please also refer to the complaints sent to Mr. Tony Watson, Solicitor, Deputy Head of Complaints and Client Relations Section at Law Society of Ireland. Ref: 22943/L/19/7 in relation to this matter.

It would appear that Mr. Henry, Tormeys Solicitors, Athlone did not undertake the instructions as requested nor did he see fit to inform us so that we could engage another Solicitor to prevent Mr. Marren, Solicitor distributing the Estate with no regard to our objections, namely to pay my sister Eileen and I the correct amount for our 1/6 share from the proceeds of the land Auction Sale, monies that were in Mr. Marren’s possession for nearly 2 years prior. Also to compensate me Michael Gavin for my work done and services rendered for the 9 years I spent looking after the Estates animals. Mr. Robert Marren, refused to award me the grant monies paid down from the Department of Agriculture and instead of going back into Court and get a Court Order directing how the estate can be distributed, Mr. Marren, Solicitor, Mullingar passed the book to my Elder sister Eileen and I and demanded court proceeding to prevent the distribution.

I do hope you can see your way to expressing your views in this matter, as I am now 83 year old and of the opinion that a grave injustice has been dealt to both my sister Eileen and I and it constitutes Elder Abuse.

Yours Sincerely

Michael Gavin

Response

justiceLaffoy

Sign the petition

Please Support Michael Gavin Elderly 83 Year Old Irish Farmer by Signing Petition

tableofcontents

Denial of Service

Sign the petition

Please Support Michael Gavin Elderly 83 Year Old Irish Farmer by Signing Petition

On Thu, Jul 30, 2015 at 11:02 AM, Denis Naughten <denis.naughten@oireachtas.ie> wrote:

Michael,
I’ve read you e-mails & blog and view your online video.
It is clear that you were very badly advised in the past not to have ensured that both you and your brother made a will to protect both sets of rights.
While there is no doubt that there are questions regarding the management of this case, the only way that these can be resolved and rectified is by the Courts.
In my 18 years in politics I have not nor will I become involved in family disputes of this nature because, in my experience, everybody loses and the only real winners are the barristers & their bank accounts.
I think that arbitration may have been useful at an earlier stage, but this ultimately is a dispute between the various beneficiaries of the will.
I’m sorry but I cannot be of assistance to you with regard to this matter.
I’m also sending a copy of this e-mail to your nephew, who has also made contact with me, on your behalf.
Yours sincerely,
Denis

Denis Naughten TD

Denis,

Totally agree with you the only way that these matters can be resolved and rectified is by the Courts

However it was Mr. Robert Marren Solicitor the administrator for the Estate that should have taken the matter to the courts to have a Judge decide not demand the Elderly Beneficiaries to issue proceedings when there were known objections.

Tony Henry Tormeys Solicitors did nothing except sit on the files for 3 months. He was instructed by John Glynn Solicitor to write and phone Marren immediately to prevent Marren closing.

It appears that he too wanted to play God in the matter. Why if he was not prepared to act on our behalf did he not have the common decency to phone us and say so. A Solicitor not undertaken an instruction is a very very serious matter and many have been disciplined for same in the past according to the records on line which are referred to in the blog.

I doubt very much that Marren or Henry would work for nothing yet they appear to think that they have a right to play God in my case.

John Glynn helped us write many a letter to Marren on un-headed paper pointing out the fact that Marren should seek a court order to direct how the Estate should be Administrated. Apparently that is common practice if when agreement can not be reached between the beneficiaries of an Estate.

Thank you for taking the time to read the blog!

However in view of the fact that you did, how can Marren holding on my 1/6 share and my sisters 1/6 share of the monies from the land sale for nearly 2 years be explained??

There is no good reason why Marren did not pay these monies to us when he received them!

What he did pay out in the end was €12,500 each short of what we were entitled to plus interest with no acceptable explanation to date as to why he did same.

It appears he also refuses also to pay John Glynn the money he claims some €50k plus for his services…yet he had no issue paying T&N Mc Lynn a year or so prior to closing.

Why do they continually scourge me with their petty battles, what has it got to do with me? and why does Marren threaten Eileen and I that he will not pay John Glynn’s bill while we seek justice through the law society. How are they related??

We are now told Willie Penrose was not paid, not that we were ever given an invoice for his services, but Marren did deduct for it.

Eileen and i never met with Penrose and we only met with Marren once and all he wanted to discuss was us making our wills….what had that got to do with the Administration of my late brothers Estate, or what business was it of his anyway whether we had our will made or not.

It would appear that because Marren is the Son in Law of Aidan O’Carroll a prominent retired Solicitor in Athlone that none of the Solicitors in the Midlands are prepared to act on our behalf.

However we intend to expose the INJUSTICE and ELDER ABUSE we have been subjected too in the public domain and thereby encourage more in our situation to stand up to the Bully Boy tactics lies and deceit that our justice system is riddled with.

I am 83 year of age and I do not deserve to be treated in this fashion. I have worked hard all my life and never wronged any man and if a pair of white bellied bast***S think they can take advantage of my Elder Widowed sister and I they have another thing coming.

Did you have a chance to read the repulsive letter Tony Henry of Tormeys Solicitors sent to Eileen yesterday(copy attached), we were deprived of sleep and up half the night scribbling a response to same. They call them selves educated and yet he had the cheek to  criticizes my signature, what has he a but an arrogant scratch of a line get more from a 2 year old, at least mine spells out my GOOD name.

We are not satisfied with the service on offer in this country to deal with this Injustice and Elder Abuse and as far as we are concerned a country that does not look after its Elderly is no country. To date the only real sympathy and support we have received is from the ordinary people while the rest of yea pluck out one excuse or another as to why yea cannot or do not help out in these matters. Well yea wont sweep this under the carpet and hide away from the facts we have copies of all the correspondence and recall  what went on.

Have a nice day!

Michael Gavin

Please Support Michael Gavin Elderly 83 Year Old Irish Farmer by Signing Petition

——————————————————————————————————————————————————

 

Email from father in Law

Dear Sir,

I received, as did many others, your email in relation to the administration of the estate of your late brother Pat Gavin.   I have retired as a Solicitor for some years but I have no record of you ever consulting me in relation to this matter.   Your sister Eileen  did mention it to me some years ago and I told her I was not prepared to act or otherwise get involved.

I would appreciate if you would not correspond with me further or include me in your mailing list in relation to this matter.

Yours faithfully,

Aiden O’Carroll

AidenoCarroll

———————————————————————————————————————————————–

Email from Fergal Monaghan MSc.

Fergal Monaghan

Fergal Monaghan

I have no idea why you are sending this material to me or for that matter to other agricultural advisors. This issue is no concern of mine and I would appreciate if you would refrain from attempts to involve me in your dispute.”

bully

Michael Gavin’s humble response to Monaghan

fergal monaghan response

tableofcontents

Sign the petition

Please Support Michael Gavin Elderly 83 Year Old Irish Farmer by Signing Petition

Letter to Robert Marren Solicitor Fighting for Justice

Sign the petition

Please Support Michael Gavin Elderly 83 Year Old Irish Farmer by Signing Petition

Mr Robert Marren                                                                                           Dundonnell

Castle Street,                                                                                                   Taughmaconnell,

Mullingar                                                                                                         Co. Roscommon.

Co. Westmeath.

 

Date: 11/07/2015

 

Mr. Marren,

 

Further to the letter my brother Michael Gavin and I received from John Glynn, Solicitor Patrick Hogan & Co. on 9th July 2015 which states

“I telephoned Mr. Marren today to enquire why I had not received payment on the basis that absolutely everybody else in the Estate has been paid and his response was that he continued to receive letters from you complaining about fees while threatening to go to the Law Society. He said he was not prepared to pay out my fees while these threats existed.”

The letter also states

“it would appear he will not pay out these fees unless you write him and confirm to him that you are not objecting to my fees and direct him to pay same. If you are not prepared to do so, you will leave me with no choice but to proceed to taxation of costs and then subsequently. I will be obliged to sue Mr. Marren for recovery of my fees. This is grossly unfair situation in that Pat is dead almost ten years. I have not been paid for any of my services rendered either to you or to the Estate over that period.”

Our objections to the above are as follows;

We do not consider our reporting you to the Law Society a threat. We have every right to seek justice for the unjust and unfair way we have been dealt with and taken advantage of considering our age, by you the administrator and the beneficiaries of the Estate to the extent that it constitutes ELDER ABUSE.

In the event that the Law Society of Ireland does not accept that our 8 complaints of inadequate professional services, alleged over charging and misconduct, warrant investigation we have every intention of referring this matter to the independent Adjudicator, the solicitors disciplinary tribunal Dublin , An Garda Síochána and the Health Service Executive HSE. Although this whole matter is a source of embarrassment to us, we will have no hesitation in disclosing same in the public domain, as it is our belief that the general public have a right to be made aware of the events that took place and let them judge for themselves based on the true facts.

While we have every intent of pursuing you vigorously to meet our demands to include recovery of the funds not distributed to us to date, we fail to see the logic to your persistent reluctance to pay Patrick Hogan & Co. in isolation to our efforts to seek justice in this matter, or “threats” as you put it.

This is reminiscent of the manner in which you dealt with paying out our 1/6 share from the sale of the Estate lands. Here again despite our persistent requests you Mr. Robert Marren refused to pay out same until finalising the distribution during the Christmas period 2014-2015, without addressing our objections, and it appears you did same to avoid paying our 1/6 share of the land from auction in isolation to the rest of the estate, notwithstanding the fact that the moneys for same were in your possession nearly 2 years previously. You have yet to provide a reasonable explanation of why you did not “bite the bullet” and pay over the full amount when you Mr. Robert Marren received the funds way back on 27th of May 2013.

Do you not recall that I wrote to you on 11th April 2015 and stated “Please advise us of any outstanding bills, has John Glynn, Hogan & Co. been paid to date, and if not why not.”

I believe this should make it clear to you that there is no objection to Patrick Hogan & Co. fee being paid.

In your response on 22nd April you Mr. Marren state “Mr Tony Mclynn was the Solicitor in High Court proceedings on behalf of some of the parties and was awarded his costs by Order of the High Court as was Hogan & Company.”

Based on your response we felt that the fees to Patrick Hogan & Co. were paid. However if you felt we objected to the fees to Patrick Hogan & Co. why did you not question the issue then.

We have never ever threatened you in any way, and most certainly not in regard to fees to Patrick Hogan & Co.

It would appear to us your reluctance Mr. Marren to paying the fee to Patrick Hogan & Co. in isolation of our “threats” as you put it are just another example of your BULLY BOY TACTICS and we do not appreciate the manner in which you Mr. Marren attempt to force us to concede to your demands by refusing to “pay out Patrick Hogan & Co. fees while these threats exist”.

You may also recall a letter was also sent to your office in Mullingar on 17TH of June 2015 stating the following;

“I take issue with your reluctance to provide a detailed breakdown of how the figure of €40,892.53 representing fees paid to Robert Marren & Co. were arrived at. I also feel I am entitled to a breakdown of all other fees paid out of the Estate funds and who was paid what at closing.

I also take issue with your persistent reluctance to provide the following

  1. Bill of Cost for T & N McLynn, Solicitors, Athlone
  2. Correct invoice for Catherine O’Conner. Her invoice states Total Amount Due €584.25 while Cash Account dated 18th July, 2014 “Fees paid to Catherine O’ Connor €6,857.25.
  3. Invoice for William Penrose B.L. or explanation of why his opinion was sought.
  4. Invoice for John Dolan Auctioneer and breakdown of the handsome fee he was paid.
  5. Answer to “has John Glynn, Hogan & Co. Ballinasloe been paid to date, and if not why not”?
  6. Answer to “has John Glynn, Hogan & Co. Ballinasloe been paid to date, and if not why not”?
  7. Any outstanding bills.”

We have yet to receive a response to that letter above which we sent register post notwithstanding the fact that these questions were posed to you in previous correspondence numerous times prior and regardless we have a right to be furnished with copies of same. You Mr. Robert Marren will note that points 5 and 6 of that letter of 17TH of June 2015, are one in the same and we underlined if not why not”? in an effort to draw your attention to same which apparently you have yet to do.

Why were we not provided with a Bill of Cost for T & N McLynn, Solicitors, Athlone who we were informed was paid their handsome amount of €38,941.00 approximately a year prior to your finalised distribution during the Christmas period 2014-2015.

When exactly was T & N McLynn, Solicitors, Athlone paid and why were they paid in advance of the finalised distribution while you refused to pay our 1/6 share of the land from auction or fees to Patrick Hogan & Co.??

You did not seek our approval for T & N McLynn, Solicitors bill nor did you request if we objected to same after they represented the other side beneficiaries who put the Estate of my late brother Patrick Gavin to enormous legal expense with their High Court Special Summons where they sought to sell the roof over my head among other things.

“By notices in writing Kathleen ‘OKeefe, and Mary Theresa Harte have confirmed their desire to have the house and lands of the estate sold. Nicholas Duffy and his four children have also confirmed that they desire to have the property sold. It is also the wish of the Plaintiff that the property be sold.”

Bearing in mind that the beneficiaries namely Anne Sanford, Kathleen O’Keefe, Mike Harte, Brenda Harte Waters, Michelle Harte, Philomena Duffy, Patrick Duffy, Catherine Duffy and Noel Duffy and their Solicitor T & N McLynn were well aware that Michael Gavin was entitled to live in the home for the rest of his days per his father’s will which they were all furnished with a copy of. As we recall we were required to attend the high court on 3 separate days, the first of which none of the beneficiaries attended. On the second day we were informed by our barrister Donal Keane B.L. that they were in another room arguing amongst themselves, and then finally we got before the judge on the third day. This is just one of the numerous examples of their vengeful, spiteful behaviour where they squandered the Estate assets. Not to mention the inconvenience, and additional expenses that were incurred to hire a man to mind the “Estate Animals” for 3 days, there was no mention of any funds to cover that cost in your finalised distribution.

On another occasion which we kept you update on, we recall one of the beneficiaries Kathleen O’Keefe rushed us into signing a lease agreement on 27th August, 2014 without providing us an opportunity to read over same carefully or to consider the matter. Consequently we were forced to get legal advice in order to amend a number of the conditions including Michael Gavin’s agreement to “having fully restored the lands to grassland by ploughing and reseeding by no later than the 31st of July 2015.” Lands that were never used for tillage, and even if they were who would commit to a short term 1 year lease with that condition. This appears underhanded to us and highlights the inadequate professional service provided by their Solicitor T&N McLynn, Athlone. It is not of a quality that could reasonably be expected of a solicitor and served no purpose other than to force us to incur additional unnecessary expenses for legal advice to draft letters in response to the lease agreement Kathleen O’Keefe tricked me Michael Gavin into signing.

You have not provided the correct invoice for Catherine O’Conner. Her invoice states Total Amount Due €584.25 while Cash Account dated 18th July, 2014 “Fees paid to Catherine O’ Connor €6,857.25.

You did not seek our approval for seeking William Penrose B.L opinion. No Invoice for William Penrose B.L. or explanation of why his opinion was sought.

You did not seek our approval for John Dolan Auctioneer. No Invoice for John Dolan Auctioneer and breakdown of the fee he was paid was provided to us to date. As we recall the auctioneer John Dolan did advertise the auction extensively and I recall full and half page ads appeared in the local newspapers. We would argue that based on the amount of interest and bids made at the auction that these ads served no purpose other than to promote John Dolans Auctioneering service as a whole. To be honest a free mention in the local parish newsletter would have sufficed.

You did not seek our approval for Damien Hannigan & Company Limited Chartered Accountant, Mullingar. Why was he hired against our explicate wishes to oversee the accounts of Catherine O’Conner. He charged in my opinion an excessive fee of €8,751.45 which we consider to be extremely expensive and an unnecessary expense. Although he was hired to oversee the accounts his fee is in excess of Catherine O’Conner’s fee. John Glynn, Solicitor, Patrick Hogan & Co. did not put the Estate to the additional expense of hiring an additional Accountant so it begs the question why did you?

I fail to understand why you now require me to write you and confirm to you that we are not objecting to Patrick Hogan & Co. fees and direct you to pay same. I feel this has being dealt with adequately in previous correspondence as above and I fail to understand your logic as to why this is the only bill out of them all that you require us to approve.

It would appear that there is a personal axe to grind between your own good self and John Glynn, Solicitor, Patrick Hogan & Co. and you have no business drawing us into your personal battles between members of your own profession.

In our opinion it would be more befitting of you to write to each of the beneficiaries namely Anne Sanford, Wesley, Mass USA, Kathleen O’Keefe, Glanmire, Cork, Mike Harte,Wesley, Mass USA, Brenda Harte Waters Quincy, Mass USA, Michelle Harte Wesley, Mass USA, Philomena Duffy Mayo, Patrick Duffy, Clare, Catherine Duffy, Monksland, Athlone and Noel Duffy, Athlone, as I have done and claw back the monies owed to us.

They cannot on the one hand expect to receive the monies from the sale of my late brother Pat Gavin’s livestock together with the gross payments received from the Department of Agriculture, without incurring any expense for the minding, looking after and caring for the animals down through the years.

Catherine O’Conner’s Account Summary 24/02/2012 shows that throughout the entire farming period between 2005 and 2012 the cattle sales came to a figure of €46,589 and the expenses came to a figure of €45,918. Accordingly, the expenses in running the farm were almost equal to the proceeds of sale of livestock. Therefore the profit from the farming operation represented the monies received each year from the Department of Agriculture under the single Payment Scheme, the Disadvantaged Area Scheme and any other Schemes of the Department of Agriculture, less any income tax payable to the state arising out of the farming operation.

We and those we have spoken to in relation to this matter FAIL to see the logic to your reluctance Mr. Robert Marren to see reason in this matter, how do you expect a person to labour for free for 9 years at their own expense and pay vets fees and fodder to fatten cattle so that those THAT DO NOTHING can reap the rewards of the GROSS profits. I Michael Gavin believe with every bone in my body that I am entitled to be paid for the work done and services rendered and monies expended by me in looking after my brother’s livestock from the time my brother died up to the time the animals were sold, this you will appreciate involved the daily herding and looking after the animals to include feeding of the animals in Winter months to include purchase of food stuffs and discharging vets fees etc.

By denying me Michael Gavin a half share in the profits it means that Michael Gavin WAS WORKING FOR NOTHING over the years in question from October, 2005 through to 2013. This is totally unjust and totally unacceptable to us.

We will not accept the present situation which is totally unfair and leaves Michael Gavin without any compensation whatsoever for the time and trouble in looking after the animals on behalf of the estate and also deprives Michael Gavin of any profit he may have earned in the rearing and looking after his own animals.

The detailed breakdown of the net amount €xxx,xxx.11 due to Michael Gavin out of the Single Payment Entitlements representing his ½ share in the profits from farming the lands, was sent to you Mr. Marren, Solicitor, on the 5th of December, 2015 for your consideration. You will note that all that Michael Gavin is looking for is his fair share of the profits in the running of the farm and fair compensation for the work Michael Gavin did in looking after the animals.

It would appear that you Mr. Robert Marren delayed making the decision regarding Michael Gavin’s share in the farming profits and rightful share of the grant monies received from the Department of Agriculture until the very end with the draft distribution account that contained countless errors on 18thSeptember, 2014. Michael Gavin was lied to countless times and led to believe that he would be refunded at closing by some of the beneficiaries. Why did you Mr. Robert Marren make a decision around March 2013 to accept Michael Gavin’s claim to owning half the livestock and all the sheep? But yet for no logical reason refused to award him the net amount €xxx,xxx.11 due to Michael Gavin out of the Single Payment Entitlements representing my ½ share in the profits from farming the lands, which was also sent to you on the 5th of December, 2015 for your consideration. There is no good reason why you took advantage of Michael Gavin’s good nature and delayed his decision in this matter until the end.

You would have received a letter from Michael Gavin on 5th December, 2014 stating;

“If a fair allowance is not made on an agreed basis, I will not give my consent to any distribution account prepared by you. Similarly, my sisters will also have to agree before a distribution account can be finalised and a distribution effected. Accordingly you as Administrator will be unable to distribute the estate unless you can procure agreement between us and, if this agreement is not forthcoming, I am advised the only way you, as Administrator, can be protected is to go back into Court and get a Court Order directing how the estate can be distributed.”

However Mr. Marren you passed the book to us and demanded court proceedings to prevent the distribution in a short space of time over the Christmas period 2014-2015.

 

We believe that you Mr. Robert Marren should NOT have finalised the distribution without addressing our objections, and it appears you did same to avoid paying our €xx,500 1/6 share of the land from action in isolation to the rest of the estate.

While it would appear that these are matters that can only be dealt with by the court if they cannot be resolved by agreement I believe it should be the Administrator who goes back into Court to get a Court Order directing how the estate can be distributed not the ELDERLY BENEFICIARIES.

It would also appear that Mr. Henry of Tormeys Solicitors, Athlone facilitated you Mr. Marren by not phoning you or writing you immediately as requested by John Glynn Solicitor, (14/01/2015 John Glynn Patrick Hogan & Co. to Tony Henry Tormeys Solicitors, Athlone requesting him to ring and write a short letter to Mr. Marren immediately confirming that he would act in the matter in response to Marren’s threat to effect a distribution of the Estate.) nor did Mr. Henry of Tormeys Solicitors, Athlone inform us, so that we could engage another Solicitor to act on behalf of Michael Gavin and Eileen Linney.

We have difficulty understanding why Mr. Henry of Tormeys Solicitors, Athlone failed to respond to correspondence, including correspondence that was crucial and significant to us.

At a subsequent meeting with Mr. Henry after your closing he estimated that court proceedings to sue you could take up to 3 years with fees in the region of €60,000 to €100,000, and he suggested that I Michael Gavin should take my age (83) into consideration.

It would appear you allowed confusion to arise in relation to the exact disbursement of funds and showed a complete disregard for the interests of the beneficiaries, whom you, Mr. Robert Marren a Solicitor, knew to be ELDERLY, and by your conduct is depriving two of the ELDERLY beneficiaries, of the enjoyment of their share in the estate. You have also forced Michael Gavin and Eileen Linney to incur additional unnecessary expenses in drafting documents and letters time and time again to prove their claim.

Yours Faithfully

Michael Gavin

Visit my blog https://michaelgavindundonnell.wordpress.com/

Sign the petition

Please Support Michael Gavin Elderly 83 Year Old Irish Farmer by Signing Petition

Response from email

Fergal Monaghan

Fergal Monaghan

I have no idea why you are sending this material to me or for that matter to other agricultural advisors. This issue is no concern of mine and I would appreciate if you would refrain from attempts to involve me in your dispute.”

 

fergal monaghan response

ghandi

“Please forgive me Mr. Fergal Monaghan MSc. for disturbing you with the material, I was merely attempting to alert you and the other agricultural advisors of the fact that I did not receive my rightful share of the grant monies paid down from the Department of Agriculture and as a result I worked for nothing for the 9 years in question. I can a sure you and your agricultural advisor colleagues that the material I sent you namely the letter above was not in anyway an attempt by me to involve yea in my dispute and I do sincerely apologist for giving you that impression”  Regards Michael Gavin

ANSBACHER

FOLLOW2

facebook-logo

Twitter-icon

tableofcontents

Sign the petition

Please Support Michael Gavin Elderly 83 Year Old Irish Farmer by Signing Petition